West German and East German comparisons in late 1940's, film 17156
Rare copy of a 1949
West German "propaganda" film comparing the two cities
Dresden (
East Germany) and
Stuttgart (West Germany). Polemics against Eastern ideology (
Communism) and pointing out the advantages of the
Western ideology. Dresden is still in ruins while
Stuttgart is largely reconstructed and prospers.
Map of Germany. Stuttgart (West Germany) and Dresden (East Germany) are marked.
Good example of early
Cold War propaganda film just after
World War Two
"Dresden of today".
Views from the Augustusbruecke (a bridge).
Street scenes. Trams. A newspaper stand.
Traffic policeman giving signs (on a nearly empty street).
Long shot of ruined streets, bombed buildings. A tram stop.
People waiting
. In the background bombed buildings. A stand of the "Aufbau-Tombola" (
Lottery for
Reconstruction). "Four years ago, 80 % of the city have been destroyed.
Today, still nearly 80 % of the city are destroyed." A child buys a lottery ticket and wins a wooden toy trailer. -
Walls with many posters. "A city of posters. Of
... communist posters." Posters: "
Fight For
Berlin!" - "the will of the proletarians: Antifascist democratic union of
Germany" - "
Song of
Siberia" (a movie). - "Activists, volunteer!" - "Two years
Plan..."
Old people reading the posters.
Narrator: "The communist strategy: more production, better living - and waiting for the next two-years-plan."
Poor people. Long queue in front of a Konsum food shop.
Spirits in a shop window. A butcher's shop selling firewood. "
The people lack food."
Shop window of a gift shop. "They wait today as they did in
1945 and 1946 and
1947 and 1948." Shop window of a food shop. A closed food shop. Posters saying: "
Don't pay too high prices!" Tobacconist's shop window.
A man in a ruined street. A street
sign in
Cyrillic letters.
The Park Hotel.
The station. Depot of steam engines put out of operation. Pan from railway tracks to overview of Dresden. A moving train... - the map superimposed... - Stuttgart. The main station from above. In the station hall. People.
Outside the station. Street scenes; trams, people.
Newspaper stand.
Photography of Stuttgart in 1945 (in ruins). Same view today: Reconstructed buildings. Pan over roofs and buildings. Along a shopping street: "No political posters.
Instead food and goods."
Shop windows: saucepans.
Clothes.
Shoes.
Suits.
China.
Suitcases and hand bags.
Busy shopping street (camera in car driving along).
Inside a sandwich shop. A big and busy market hall from above.
Fish stand. Egg stand. (
Meanwhile the narrator talks about the advantages of the Western ideology of free enterprise, democracy etc.)
Butter / cheese stand. Tinned vegetables.
Meat stand. A sign: "
Ohne Marken!" (no food stamps needed!) big vegetable stand.
The market hall from the outside. Overview of the area. Reconstructed big buildings. A crane at a building site.
The town hall with a new roof. Dwelling houses with scaffolds.
Big hospital with scaffold.
Cinema (the "Palastlichtspiele") showing "Ninotschka".
Shots of building sites.
Conveyor belts. A machine making bricks out of debris. Scaffolds, workers with wheelbarrows. Bricklaying. An orchestra giving an open-air performance in a park.
Audience. "This, therefore, is the story of two cities." Juxtapositions:
Ruins in Dresden - Reconstructed buildings in Stuttgart.
Empty shop window in Dresden - Shop window with food in Stuttgart. Posters in Dresden ("empty promises") - reconstructed bell tower in Stuttgart ("kept promises"). Ruins in Dresden - lively streets in Stuttgart.