Commentary Archive
Submarine state
On secrets and leaksby Daniel Nemenyi / RP 193 (Sept/Oct 2015) / Commentary
It’s not answerable to anyone, given it doesn’t exist in law; no minutes are kept; and it’s confidential. No citizen ever knows what is said within… These are decisions of almost life and death, and no member has to answer to anybody.
The politics of counting and the scene of rescue
Border deaths in the Mediterraneanby Martina Tazzioli / RP 192 (July/Aug 2015) / Commentary
Border deaths are not a new phenomenon. Since the early 2000s, the Mediterranean Sea has been named a ‘maritime cemetery’ by activists [1] and critical migration scholars. However, over the last two years migrant deaths at the borders have gained more and more attention in the media and EU political debate …
The signature of security
Big data, anticipation, surveillanceby Claudia Aradau / RP 191 (May/Jun 2015) / Commentary, Data & Surveillance
‘We are not crystal ball gazers. We are Intelligence Agencies’, noted the former GCHQ director Iain Lobban in a public inquiry on privacy and security by the Intelligence and Security Committee of the UK Parliament (ISC) in the wake of the Snowden revelations about mass surveillance. [1] Several minutes later, Lobban …
Big data, small freedom?
Informational surveillance and the politicalby Burkhardt Wolf / RP 191 (May/Jun 2015) / Commentary, Data & Surveillance
In 2010, ‘big data’ was described as ‘datasets that could not be captured, managed and processed by general computers within an acceptable scope’. [1] Today’s definitions boil down to three Vs: Variety, Volume and Velocity. Big data deals with mostly unstructured, heterogeneous and non-validated data, whose size is so big that …
Oceanic enemy
A brief philosophical history of the NSAby Gregoire Chamayou / RP 191 (May/Jun 2015) / Commentary, Data & Surveillance
6 July 1962, NAVFAC base, Barbados.
A grey building stands at the foot of a stone lighthouse overlooking the Caribbean Sea. Inside, a military serviceman is examining the lines being recorded on an enormous roll of paper by the stylus of a sort of gigantic electrocardiogram. We are in one of the secret bases of …
![Item accessible to subscribers or available for single purchase](http://web.archive.org./web/20150906130355im_/http://www.radicalphilosophy.com/wp-content/themes/frankfurt/images/locked.gif)
Food politics in the USA
by Allan Stoekl / RP 190 (Mar/Apr 2015) / CommentaryNutrition in food is, today, a function of profitability: junk food and processed foods are more profitable than organics grown locally; meat is not only more energy intensive, but is more profitable (at least for those who package and market it). People’s diets are, in other words, determined not simply by what is grown or …
Old alliances, new struggles
The Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnershipby Maïa Pal / RP 190 (Mar/Apr 2015) / Commentary
The Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) is a bilateral agreement between the European Union and the United States of America aimed at the liberalization and regulation of trade in goods and services. If adopted, it will supplant the EU, the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) and the deal between China and the Association …
Russell Brand, Lady T, Pisher Bob and Preacher John
by Raymond Geuss / RP 190 (Mar/Apr 2015) / CommentaryRussell Brand’s new book Revolution * is an impressive contribution to political philosophy, a field which during the past thirty years or so has not been overly populated with interesting work. Brand’s argument can be summarized in ten steps:
Our lives are to a large extent given structure by a set of economic practices and …
Bruno Latour’s anthropology of the moderns
A reply to Maniglierby Gunnar Skirbekk / RP 189 (Jan/Feb 2015) / Commentary
An Inquiry into Modes of Existence: An Anthropology of the Moderns – published with the motto: si scires donum Dei (for those who do not know the Holy Scripture, this is John 4.10: ‘if you knew God’s gift’) – is said to be the result of Bruno Latour’s research over the last twenty-five years. [1] The book …
Green economics versus growth economics
The case of Thomas Pikettyby Rupert Read / RP 189 (Jan/Feb 2015) / Commentary
What would be a radical economics today? It would have two components. First, it must understand economics as necessarily political economy; as a continuous human, social creation subject to political manipulation and to new positive political vision and action. Second, it must be a Green ecological economics. That is, it must have absorbed the …
Alternative economics
A new student movementby Engelbert Stockhammer and Devrim Yilmaz / RP 189 (Jan/Feb 2015) / Commentary
Economics is in crisis. The profession is under attack from the media, employers and the general public. The economists we are producing are not performing the tasks society demands from them. [1 ]
The recent global crisis not only led to a questioning of mainstream macroeconomic theories and their relevance …
Legal terror and the police dog
by Tyler Wall / RP 188 (Nov/Dec 2014) / CommentaryIn Johnstown, Pennsylvania, in 2001 an off-duty police officer spotted Antonio Chatman, who was known by this officer as having a warrant for a misdemeanour. Soon other officers, including a K-9 unit, arrived on the scene. Chatman attempted to flee but a police dog pursued and apprehended him, which is to say the trained dog …
Deadly Algorithms
Can legal codes hold software accountable for code that kills?by Susan Schuppli / RP 187 (Sept/Oct 2014) / Commentary
Algorithms have long adjudicated over vital processes that help to ensure our well-being and survival, from pacemakers that maintain the natural rhythms of the heart, and genetic algorithms that optimise emergency response times by cross-referencing ambulance locations with demographic data, to early warning systems that track approaching storms, detect seismic activity, and even seek …
Boycotting Israel
Academia, activism and the futures of American Studiesby Mandy Merck / RP 186 (Jul/Aug 2014) / Commentary
On 4 December of last year, the annual conference of the American Studies Association resolved that ‘whereas the United States plays a significant role in enabling the Israeli occupation of Palestine … whereas there is no effective or substantive academic freedom for Palestinian students and scholars under conditions of Israeli occupation, and Israeli institutions of …
‘Yes’
A non-nationalist argument for Scottish independenceby Neil Davidson / RP 185 (May/Jun 2014) / Commentary
On the evening of 16 May 1973, around halfway through the Aladdin Sane tour, I watched David Bowie play his second sold-out show at the Aberdeen Music Hall. I could not have imagined that one day I would be listening to him – or, rather, listening to Kate Moss speaking on his behalf – intervene …
‘People not of our concern’
by Martina Tazzioli / RP 184 (Mar/Apr 2014) / Commentary‘We stay here and we don’t move.’ This is the refrain in the Choucha refugee camp among those who have been stranded there, in the desert, since 2011. ‘Rejected’ and ‘non-resettled refugees’ are the categories through which these migrant stories have been sorted. They are also the terms that determine the UN Refugee Agency’s (UNHCR) …
Dissonances of the Arab Left
by Hisham Bustani / RP 184 (Mar/Apr 2014) / CommentaryTo talk of the secular democratic leftist project in the Arab world is to talk of crisis – a crisis that is manifest in two ways. First, there is the fundamental question of whether such a project even exists in a coherent and comprehensive form, rather than as a mere collection of statements and propositions …
Generative grafting
Reproductive technology and the dilemmas of surrogacyby Elina Staikou / RP 183 (Jan/Feb 2014) / Commentary
In 2013, at the advanced age of 101, Howard W. Jones, a medical pioneer in reproductive technology, published Personhood Revisited: Reproductive Technology, Bioethics, Religion and the Law. Looking back at the development of what came to be called the ARTs (assisted reproductive technologies), Jones chronicles the initial controversies surrounding their emergence and his own participation …
Kleptography
by Finn Brunton / RP 183 (Jan/Feb 2014) / CommentaryOne must remember that mathematics, like death, never makes mistakes, never plays tricks. If we are unable to see those irrational curves or solids, it means only that they inevitably possess a whole immense world somewhere beneath the surface of our life.
– Yevgeny Zamyatin, We
The settings alone brush perilously close to fiction: a …
Smells like Gezi spirit
Democratic sensibilities and carnivalesque politics in Turkeyby Meyda Yeğenoğlu / RP 182 (Nov/Dec 2013) / Commentary
A small protest in Istanbul, which began by aiming to protect the urban greenery, was rapidly turned into a full-blown nationwide resistance. The protests should be regarded as the most important outcry of the Turkish people since the 1980 coup, and herald a new period in the history of Turkey. But it would be …