Photo Booth

October 8, 2013

North via South: Mesoamerican Brutalism

  • MBiernat_Brutalism-01.jpgCaja Costarricense de Seguro Social, San Jose, Costa Rica. Architect: Alberto Linner.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-02.jpgStela A, Great Plaza, Copán ruins, Honduras. A depiction of 18 Rabbit, the thirteenth Mayan king of Copán, who ruled for over forty years, starting in the late six hundreds, and who was the architect of Copán’s most elaborate structures.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-03.jpgMinistry of the Environment, energy-and-telecommunications building, San Jose, Costa Rica.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-04.jpgChitchen Itza, Yucatan, Mexico. Possibly the most famous Mayan landmark, the Kukulkan pyramid, in Chichen Itza, was used to read the stars. On the vernal and autumnal equinoxes, the shadows cast by the stairways resemble a giant snake.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-05.jpgInterior of the Metropolitan Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception, Managua, Nicaragua. Architect: Ricardo Legorreta.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-06.jpgUxmal ruins, Yucatan, Mexico.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-07.jpgBank of Guatemala building complex, Guatemala City. Mural artist: Roberto González Goyri.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-08.jpgReplica Stela with Mayan hieroglyphics, Iximché ruins, Guatemala.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-09.jpgCopán ruins, Honduras
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-10.jpgCentro Cultural Miguel Ángel Asturias, Guatemala City. Architect: Eran Recinos. Recinos’s idea was for the building to emulate a reclining jaguar.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-11.jpgContraloria General de la Republica, San Jose Costa Rica. Architect: Raúl Goddard.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-12.jpgTemple I, Tikal, Guatemala.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-13.jpgCentral Library, National Autonomous University of Mexico, Mexico City. Architect, Juan O’Gorman.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-14.jpgRosalila Temple Replica, Copán ruins, Honduras. This replica is a one-to-one scale model of the original temple, buried inside the ruins of Copán. Because of its burial, the coloring and detail of the original was perfectly preserved.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-15.jpgViewing platform, Volcán Irazú, Costa Rica.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-16.jpgIximché ruins, Guatemala. At Iximché, our guide’s first language was not Spanish but the Mayan dialect Kaqchikel, which was spoken by the Mayans who ruled here.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-17.jpgNational Library of Mexico, National Autonomous University of Mexico, Mexico City. Architect: Orso Nuñez.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-18.jpgA Mayan corbel arch, Uxmal, Yucatan, Mexico.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-19.jpgThe Luis Barragán House, Mexico City. The Casa Luis Barragán is a temple to the architect’s philosophy of architectural simplicity and harmony with nature. In his later career he abandoned architecture altogether, to pursue garden design.
  • MBiernat_Brutalism-20.jpgNunnery, Chichen Itza, Yucatan, Mexico. Conquistadors who first explored the ruins at Chichen Itza thought this complex reminiscent of nunneries in Europe.

Today, we’ll check in with Magda Biernat and Ian Webster, as they continue their journey from Antarctica to Alaska, which they began in January of this year. “Beginning in San Jose, Costa Rica, we were pleased to see a rise in the number of Brutalist buildings,” Ian told me.

This architectural style was developed after a world weary of war dropped the pretenses of beauty from the façades of government buildings and went all in on a new kind of populist expression of power. In Central America, as elsewhere, the new style dovetailed neatly with a fledgling socialist movement and an explosion of low-cost postwar growth. Today, Brutalism has more critics than admirers, but there is something to be said for its play of repetitive shapes, offset angles, and soaring geometrics. Granted, this is probably not what most tourists are searching for when they visit Central America, but since Magda is an architectural photographer and we are both fans of these bold, clean architectural declarations, we went out of our way to find them.

When we visited the ruins of the Mayan city-states for the first time, we were struck by the similarities—some intentional, some not—between Mesoamerican architecture and their comparably recent Brutalist counterparts. The Mayan temples were originally as ornate as any neoclassical edifice in Europe, but they’ve since been stripped down to their essential form by wars, looting, and the passage of time. As they’ve atrophied, they’ve achieved the goal of the Brutalists: a purity of form and an unadorned statement of grandeur.

Above is a selection of Magda’s photographs of Brutalist buildings contrasted with Mayan ruins, accompanied by Ian’s captions. You can see previous Photo Booth posts from their journey, and detailed record of the trip on their blog.

To get more of The New Yorker's signature mix of politics, culture and the arts: Subscribe Now
 
Subscribe to The New Yorker
  • This Week: Links to articles and Web-only features in your inbox every Monday.
  • Cartoons: A weekly note from the New Yorker's cartoon editor.
  • Daily: What's new today on newyorker.com.
  • Receive all the latest fake news from The Borowitz Report.
I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its User Agreement, and Privacy Policy.