Comics who are stealing the show - the week in comedy

 

Frankie Boyle lost his joke
book this week. To some – the Queen, Katie Price, other objects of his
furore-baiting gags – this might be cause for celebration. To the comedian, the
loss of the small brown notebook was nothing short of a calamity. His set for a
charity gig in Glasgow was in it, for starters. More than that, to any comedian,
their notes – whether in a book, an iPhone or on the back of a beer mat, are
gold. “To you”,
said Boyle with typical charm, “It will just seem like a lot of
random sentences about rape, drone warfare & being fingered by a sign
language interpreter.” What could anyone else possibly want with that? You
can’t steal someone else’s jokes and pass them off as your own. Or can you?

Joke Thieves is a new comedy night which asks exactly that question. The two-hour show, at The King’s Head in Crouch End begins like any other mixed-bill night. Six comedians get up and do five minutes each. Everyone has a drink in the interval. And then the comedians come back and do the same jokes all over again. Only this time, they are not delivering their own material: they have swapped sets with someone else on the bill, as chosen by the audience.

The stand-up Will Mars came up with the idea earlier this year. In his previous life, working in management and sales for a holiday company, he used to encourage employees to swap patter and sales routines to keep them fresh and open to new techniques. What if comedians did the same, and a character act was forced to have a go at straight stand-up, or a whimsical storyteller tried to churn out one-liners? Is it really all about the way they tell them?

Mars started the night Downstairs at the King’s Head in June. In August, he took it to Edinburgh and the Free Fringe for a month, where it drew capacity crowds every night. “I turned away well over 1000 people over the course of the run”, he says. Now he is trialling the night with The Stand in Edinburgh, plans to take it around the festivals and to America and is developing it for television with The Comedy Unit, having turned away five other production companies.

The appeal is obvious. Joke Thieves gives audiences a glimpse of the workings behind the mic stand. Acts deliver sure-fire laughs with their usual material in the first half before having the rug pulled from under them as they step up a second time with unfamiliar set-ups and punchlines.

Most enjoyably, it really brings out the comedians’ competitive side. Determined that someone else should not spin more laughs out of their material than they do, acts often perform their most impossible to intimate routines in the first half. This week Danny Ward peppered his set with a couple of tongue-twister lists while Will Franken did a quickfire run of oddball impressions. “One act did 35 accents in her five minutes, just to mess up the comedian copying her, who couldn’t do accents at all”, saysMars.

In the second half, the fur starts to fly as comedians repeat and lovingly, or not so, tweak the routines of their co-stars live on stage. Lengthily worked-up anecdotes are paraphrased in a single offhand sentence, gags are sarkily explained – “It’s funny because he’s blind” – routines are deconstructed and everyone tries to get more laughs than their rival did first time round. Often they do. It’s a comedians’ in-joke that everyone in the room can enjoy. And for the performers, it is a rare chance to hear what their peers really think of their act. “The type of comedians it attracts are used to trying out new stuff, being uncomfortable, taking an ego hit”, says Mars. “They are all itching to annoy each other, really. And they generally take it well. We’ve not had anyone throw a hissy fit, yet.”

Naked Gun returns

“Nightcap?” “No thanks I don’t wear them”. Detective Frank Drebin and his hilarious literalism are coming back. Ed Helms, best known as the dentist who accidentally marries a stripper in The Hangover, has signed up to star in a remake of Naked Gun, taking on the role gloriously immortalised by the late Leslie Nielsen.

From Arthur to Pink Panther, the path to the multiplex is littered with terrible comedy remakes but Drebin is an idiot for the ages and Helms has good pedigree on The Daily Show and The American Office so it might just work – even if OJ Simpson is unavailable to co-star this time.

WHAT I WATCHED…

Steve Bugeja

If you like Will from The Inbetweeners, you’ll like this new stand-up. An out-and-proud nerd, in his own words: “When I was 18 I went to Magaluf with my friends for a week. And I got through eight books.” He won the BBC Radio New Comedy Award last week with this charming set http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p01n2x54

Ivo Graham

At The Tabernacle, London. This promising young comedian had a brilliant debut at the Edinburgh Fringe and is getting better and better with every gig. He also has one of the best Christmas stories I’ve heard this year.

The Double

On YouTube. Richard Ayoade’s follow-up to Submarine is based on Dostoevsky’s novella and looks like a classy affair. This teaser trailer stars Jesse Eisenberg, Mia Wasikowska, Wallace Shawn and… is that Chris Morris in the final frame? (yes it is) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQgaqe0owIk

www.twitter.com/alicevjones

Arts & Entertainment
Jennifer Lawrence is 'brilliant as the neurotic housewife' in American Hustle
film

Geoffrey Macnab reviews American Hustle, also starring Christian Bale and Bradley Cooper

Voices

elephant appealThe first 23 lots in our charity auction have now gone. But there are 22 more still up for grabs

Arts & Entertainment
Martin Freeman as Bilbo Baggins in a scene from 'The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug'
books

Michelle Nijhuis' daughter insists (s)he is, and she learnt a valuable lesson on gender in books

News
Opponents claim the bill would stop performers such as Beyonce and Madonna appearing on TV

news Opponents claim it would stop performers such as Beyonce and Madonna appearing on TV

VIDEO
Life & Style
Because there is no mixer large enough for the 700 kilos of pudding, the chefs pour the ingredients onto a large table and gather around to mix the ingredients by hand,
food + drink

It takes a platoon of chefs, litres of brandy and rum, and almost 100kg of dried fruit

News
Counting sheep: As flocks are brought down off freezing hillsides, reports are once again starting to come in of missing livestock

newsThat most ancient of crimes is on the rise, threatening farmers' livelihoods, community trust – and human health

Extras
indybest
News
scienceStudy reveals canines recognise their owners
Extras
indybestThe Independent picks its favourite pieces of tech of the year
News
Rare 1696 Stradivarius violin worth £1.2m has finally been found by police
news
Independent
Travel Shop
Bruges by Eurostar
Three nights from £259pp Find out more
All-inclusive Malta
seven nights from £249pp Find out more
Pompeii, Capri and the Bay of Naples
seven nights from £719 Find out more
Elephant Appeal donate now >

ES Rentals

    Independent Dating
    and  

    By clicking 'Search' you
    are agreeing to our
    Terms of Use.

    Sheep rustling: Fleecing the countryside

    Sheep rustling: Fleecing the countryside

    That most ancient of crimes is on the rise, threatening farmers' livelihoods, community trust – and human health
    Is Bilbo Baggins a girl?

    Is Bilbo Baggins a girl?

    On her daughter's insistence, Michelle Nijhuis turned Bilbo Baggins into a girl. She soon realised that a sex change was a great way to combat stereotypes in all sorts of stories
    The secrets behind a Ritz Christmas pudding

    The secrets behind a Ritz Christmas pudding

    It takes a platoon of chefs, litres of brandy and rum, and almost 100kg of dried fruit to make the hotel's famous festive desserts
    American Hustle, film review - 'Jennifer Lawrence is brilliant as the neurotic housewife'

    American Hustle film review

    Jennifer Lawrence is brilliant as the neurotic housewife
    Saving face: 10 best winter moisturisers

    Saving face: 10 best winter moisturisers

    Banish dry, lack-lustre complexions and get glowing with our favourite winter face-savers
    Was 2013 a better year for sport than 2012?

    Was 2013 a better year for sport than 2012?

    If you thought the London Olympics and Bradley Wiggins' Tour glory made last year the best, don't forget Andy Murray's Wimbledon win and Mo Farah's world double
    Ben Stokes: From the ashes of England ignominy, the all-rounder is rising as the real deal

    Ben Stokes interview

    From the ashes of England ignominy, the all-rounder is rising as the real deal
    The death of Dr Abbas Khan asks more questions about the Syrian regime than it answers

    Patrick Cockburn

    The death of Dr Abbas Khan asks more questions about the Syrian regime than it answers
    A new nation with old hatreds: More than 500 people feared dead after 'failed coup' in South Sudan

    A new nation with old hatreds

    More than 500 people feared dead after 'failed coup' in South Sudan
    The children who join the Cubs... and learn to kill people: Al-Qa’ida-led factions in Syria are training boys as young as 10 to become rebel fighters

    The children who join the Cubs... and learn to kill people

    Al-Qa’ida-led factions in Syria are training boys as young as 10 to become rebel fighters
    Why we must save the banana

    Why we must save the banana

    The healthy snack is under threat, with insect plagues reducing global supplies. Rosie Millard wonders where we’d be without the lovable fruit and its comic potential
    Wish it could be Christmas every day?

    Wish it could be Christmas every day?

    It takes year-long dedication to get Selfridges ready for 25 December. And they're already working on 2015...
    Call the Midwife - a special delivery

    A special delivery: Behind the scenes on the set of 'Call the Midwife'

    Ahead of its Christmas Day special, Gerard Gilbert meets the scene-stealing Miranda Hart
    It's a kind of hi-tech magic

    The open-sorcerers

    Traditionally, magicians have kept their secrets to themselves. But a growing number of illusionists believe the future lies in a hi-tech approach
    Chess on the radio: play it by ear

    Play it by ear: Chess on the radio

    It's an interesting move but not unprecedented. Jon Speelman celebrates the revival of the fine tradition of broadcasting chess games on the radio