‘The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug’ Review: Peter Jackson’s Second Verse Is Better Than the First

The Wrap
‘The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug’ Review: Peter Jackson’s Second Verse Is Better Than the First
.

View gallery

‘The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug’ Review: Peter Jackson’s Second Verse Is Better Than the First

If “The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey” was a single-serving tribute to the fans of the J.R.R. Tolkien book that inspired it, its follow up, “The Desolation of Smaug,” offers a nod to the uninitiated moviegoing audiences that made a prequel trilogy possible.

Eschewing the kitchen-sink minutiae of the first installment (or maybe just having used all of it up) Peter Jackson creates a rousing, immersive sequel that offers the same sort of sweeping action — and more crucially, emotional engagement — that helped the “Rings” films become a cultural phenomenon, regardless whether or not you were familiar with the source material.

Picking up more or less immediately where the last one left off, Bilbo Baggins (Martin Freeman) and the band of dwarves led by would-be king Thorin (Richard Armitage) continue their journey to the Lonely Mountain. On the run from Azog (Manu Bennett), an Orc with a bloodlust for Thorin’s head, they flee into Mirkwood, where they are attacked by giant spiders until elves Legolas (Orlando Bloom) and Tauriel (Evangeline Lilly) intervene and subsequently imprison them.

See video: ‘The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug’ Trailer: Dragons and Dreamy Orlando Bloom

Despite long-unresolved animosity between most dwarves and elves, Tauriel discovers an unexpected bond with one of them, Kili (Aidan Turner), even as Bilbo plots an escape. Advancing closer to the Lonely Mountain with the help of a boatman named Bard (Luke Evans), Thorin hurries the group toward their destination, hoping to unlock its secrets and restore him to the throne. Meanwhile, Gandalf (Ian McKellen) visits Dol Guldur to get a closer look at the mysterious Necromancer (Benedict Cumberbatch), only to discover an army forming to unleash the latter’s evil upon Middle Earth.

While the specificity of these destinations probably doesn’t mean much if you’re unfamiliar with Tolkien’s book — admittedly, I had to look a few of them up even after watching the film — Jackson unveils the second chapter in his trilogy with a clarity that should restore fans’ faith in his storytelling. As compelling as its mythology was, the “Lord of the Rings” films really found their footing when they uncovered the universal, relatable emotions that the characters experienced, and then applied that to the story and the action.

Also read: ‘Hunger Games: Catching Fire’ Review: Jennifer Lawrence’s Katniss Everdeen Burns Brighter Than Ever (Video)

Where the first “Hobbit” was an expository slog that, quite frankly, failed to distinguish the dwarves from one another in the way it hoped to, this one narrows its focus on the “important” ones – Thorin and Kili – and establishes stakes that make us care as the rest of them fill in the background.

Additionally, Jackson (with co-writers Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens and Guillermo del Toro) creates a new character especially for the series, Tauriel, who might seem like one too many – especially given the indistinguishability of the dwarves. As it turns out, Tauriel gives the film an emotional core that reminds the audience that, even among dragons and elves and Orcs and dwarves, all of their feelings are completely human.

Of course, Jackson also stages the action in the film with considerable flair and imagination, creating in “Smaug” some of the best set pieces of any of his Tolkien adaptations. The centerpiece barrel chase is by far the most thrilling of these sequences, in which the dwarves flee their elven captors only to encounter Orcs, but in all of them Jackson finds time to include character details – such as the elf-hating Thorin saving Legolas’ life – that enhance their dramatic impact.

See photos: Orlando Bloom, Evangeline Lilly Prepare for Battle in 7 New ‘Hobbit: Desolation of Smaug’ Character Posters

Then of course there’s Smaug himself, a spectacularly-rendered creature with more than enough gravitas to give this film’s final act real impact. In fact, the film’s only real shortcoming is its acquiescence to middle-chapter–itis; like “The Hunger Games: Catching Fire,” “The Desolation of Smaug” ends abruptly at the exact moment when you most want to see what happens next.

Nevertheless, it’s triumphantly engaging in a way that rivals Jackson’s magnificent “Two Towers” — and best of all, it makes you eager to see the next film in a way that “The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey” didn’t. Powerful and provocative, “The Desolation of Smaug” not only surpasses its predecessor but also stands on its own; where “Journey” took material audiences thought they knew and made it feel foreign, this one creates a uniquely original experience that also feels securely familiar.

The post ‘The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug’ Review: Peter Jackson’s Second Verse Is Better Than the First appeared first on TheWrap.

Related stories from TheWrap:

Orlando Bloom Admits Girls Were More Important Than Reading 'Lord of the Rings' (Video)

The Aviation of Smaug: Air New Zealand Dragonizes a Boeing to Promote 'The Hobbit'

'The Hobbit' Trailer: Smaug is King Under the Mountain

View Comments

Recommended for You

  • Film Review: ‘Expecting’

    This charm-free comedy about the repercussions of an unplanned pregnancy — the debut feature of writer-director Jessie McCormack — is hardly a bundle of joy.

    Variety
  • Credit Cards Are Now Offering 0% APR Through 2015

    Consumers can now get rid of high interest rates and get 0% APR for 18 months. Compare these leading 2013 credit card offers and find your best offer.

    AdChoices CompareCards.comSponsored
  • ’12 Years,’ ‘Enough Said’ Top Boston Critics Prizes

    Fox Searchlight was the big winner with the Boston Society of Film Critics, as its “12 Years a Slave” took top prizes for pic and director, while the distrib’s “Enough Said” won for screenplay by Nicole Holofcener and James Gandolfini as supporting actor. Paramount’s “Nebraska” was a double winner,…

    Variety
  • Marion Cotillard Talks ‘The Immigrant,’ ‘Lady Macbeth,’ Scorsese and the Dardennes Brothers

    MARRAKECH, Morocco– On top of being part of Martin Scorsese’ Jury at Marrakech Film Festival, Marion Cotillard — whose latest film, James Gray’s “The Immigrant,” played at the Morocco-based fest — cheerfully participated in roundtables with journalists. Cotillard, the first French actress to have…

    Variety
  • Keanu Reeves’ ’47 Ronin’ Debuts at No. 3 at Japanese Box Office

    Universal’s Keanu Reeves action fantasy epic “47 Ronin” made its debut in Japan over the weekend, and took in $1.3 million from 333 locations. The debut by “47 Ronin” topped two other U.S. movies in their second week in the marketplace, “Captain Phillips” and “Red 2,” but behind two Japanese…

    The Wrap
  • Play

    Five Receive Kennedy Center Honors

    Martina Arroyo, Herbie Hancock, Billy Joel, Shirley MacLaine and Carlos Santana receive the Kennedy Center honors for their contributions to American culture.

    Associated Press Videos
  • The 3 Worst Movies of 2013

    And the studios that suffered the consequences of releasing them.

    Motley Fool
  • Los Angeles Film Critics Honor 'Gravity,' 'Her'

    The Los Angeles Film Critics Association split between the space odyssey "Gravity" and the futuristic romance "Her," lending no more certainty to an awards season that's so far been full of contenders. The two films shared best picture in the awards announced Sunday by the L.A. critics, but…

    Huffington Post
  • 'Frozen' Cools Off 'The Hunger Games: Catching Fire' to Top Box Office

    In its second weekend at the box office, the Disney animated tale "Frozen" finally cooled off "The Hunger Games: Catching Fire," while the week's lone new wide release "Out of ...

    The Wall Street Journal
  • Specialty Box Office: ‘Inside Llewyn Davis’ Opens To Spectacular $100K-Plus PSA

    It was predictable that Inside Llewyn Davis would rule over the Specialty Box Office this weekend, but the question mark was how big the numbers would be for the CBS Films release. Directed by Joel and Ethan Coen and starring Oscar Isaac, folk music drama grossed a spectacular $402K in four…

    Deadline.com
  • Box Office: ‘Frozen’ Ices ‘Fire’ in Weekend Showdown; ‘Furnace’ Fails to Gain Any Heat

    As most of the nation dealt with wintry weather this weekend, it seemed fitting that Disney’s “Frozen” walked away with domestic box office crown, estimating $31.6 million, enough to eclipse Lionsgate’s “The Hunger Games: Catching Fire,” which ended the three-day frame with $27 million. In three…

    Variety
  • 'Frozen,' 'Catching Fire' fuel U.S., Canada box office

    Walt Disney Co's animated fairy tale "Frozen" heated up movie box office charts in the United States and Canada, displacing dystopian thriller "The Hunger Games: Catching Fire" as the ...

    Reuters
  • Fox Announces Another X-Men Movie. Here's What It Means for Disney.

    Director Bryan Singer takes to Twitter to announce "X-Men: Apocalypse" for 2016.

    Motley Fool
  • Deadline’s Best Film Stories Of The Week

    Catch up on Deadline’s best film stories of the week: Emerging Star Gal Gadot Set To Play Wonder Woman In ‘Batman Vs. Superman’ By Mike Fleming Jr. – Warner Bros and Zack Snyder have found their Wonder Woman. They’ve cast Israeli-born actress Gal Gadot in the iconic role and she will be part of…

    Deadline.com
  • Public Records Posted Online for Anyone to See

    Did you know that public records are posted online and can be viewed by anyone in seconds? Marriages, divorces, bankruptcies, etc. Search anyone.

    AdChoices Instant CheckmateSponsored
  • ‘Frozen’ Skates Past ‘Hunger Games: Catching Fire’ at Box Office

    A Saturday surge carried Disney’s family movie “Frozen” to No. 1 at the U.S. box office this weekend, ending the two-week reign of “The Hunger Games: Catching Fire.” The Jennifer Lawrence sequel had a slim lead with $8 million after Friday, but wound up with $27 million for second. The weekend…

    The Wrap
  • ‘Inside Llewyn Davis’ Box-Office Opening is Coen Brothers’ Best Ever

    Ethan and Joel Coens’ “Inside Llewyn Davis” gave the writer-director team their best box-office debut ever this weekend, rolling up $402,000 from just four theaters. That’s a spectacular $100,500 per-screen average for the CBS Films’ Oscar hopeful that stars Oscar Isaacs as young singer at the…

    The Wrap
  • On RoboCop: Somewhere, there is a crime happening

    Last year, Detroit decided that it needed RoboCop. Back in the near future of 1987, a corporate conglomerate named Omni Consumer Products had the same idea, but its RoboCop wasn’t a symbol of hope. It was a cynical solution to an ultraviolent future — and the protagonist of the action movie to…

    The Verge
  • ‘Stalingrad’ Producer Alexander Rodnyansky Ramps Up Russian Production Slate

    BERLIN — Alexander Rodnyansky, one of the lead producers of Fedor Bondarchuk‘s record-breaking movie “Stalingrad,”  is ramping up his slate of Russian projects. 3D World War II actioner “Stalingrad,” which is distribbed worldwide by Sony, has grossed $66.8 million so far, making it the most…

    Variety
  • 6 Huge Takeaways From ‘The Amazing Spider-Man 2′ Trailer

    What exactly did 'The Amazing Spider-Man 2' trailer reveal that has fans so excited? Here are the six biggest takeaways.

    Wall St. Cheat Sheet
  • Exclusive Book Excerpt: ‘The CG Story’: How Pixar Saved ‘Toy Story’ From Becoming A Disney Disaster

    The history of special effects and CG in film and their close relationship with today’s top-notch digital animation is the focus of author Christopher Finch’s new lavish 368-page book The CG Story: Computer Generated Animation and Special Effects, which peels the curtain back on CG pioneers like…

    Deadline.com
  • No Secret to the High Cost of 'Walter Mitty'

    Ben Stiller's $90 Million 'The Secret Life of Walter Mitty," which opens Dec. 25, took great pains to film in real-life extreme conditions, for a plot that's in large part about fantasy.

    The Wall Street Journal