Incomplete memoirs of early Egyptian anarchism 14:28 Jan 08 0 comments La breve estate di Salvador Puigh Antich 20:43 Nov 10 0 comments September 2014 Kate Sharpley Library Bulletin online 17:34 Sep 05 0 comments January/February 2014 Kate Sharpley Library Bulletin online 01:43 Feb 14 0 comments [MAD]vie10 mayo 2013, 19:30h. Diseño sin Diseño. 50 objetos anarquistas 02:42 May 08 0 comments more >> |
Recent articles by Kate Sharpley Library
“Nameless in the crowd of nameless ones…” : 0 comments October 2013 Kate Sharpley Library Bulletin online 0 comments New publication: News of the Spanish Revolution : Anti-authoritarian P... 2 comments Recent Articles about Ireland / Britain History of anarchismColin Ward's Anarchism Jan 06 15 Belfast Anarchist Group and the long march to Derry (1969) Jun 14 12 Dublin Anarchist Group, May Day 1978 Apr 30 12 Albert Meltzer and the fight for working class history
ireland / britain |
history of anarchism |
opinion / analysis
Saturday October 26, 2013 19:38 by Kate Sharpley Library - KSL
Albert Meltzer was a central figure in the development of the Kate Sharpley Library, both practically (laying out and distributing the bulletin and pamphlets) and also philosophically. Albert Meltzer and the fight for working class historyAlbert Meltzer was a central figure in the development of the Kate Sharpley Library, both practically (laying out and distributing the bulletin and pamphlets) and also philosophically. His concern at seeing the history of anarchism rewritten to suit other people’s agendas was part of the motivation for the founding of the Library. [1] It also connected with the rest of his anarchism: class-conscious, committed to liberation from below, sceptical of ‘experts’ and unafraid of criticising them. His historical writing, like all of his writing, was punchy, humorous and anecdotal. ‘Our historical judgement was criticised as based only on anecdotal history from veterans but knowing how conventional history is concocted I doubt if it suffered from that.’ [2] Albert wrote anarchist history from his own experience and the accounts of comrades he knew. He did not have the leisure (or the patience) to comb through archives. He also knew that relying on published sources could write the people who made up the anarchist movement out of history. To Albert, most academics had proven themselves incapable of understanding the anarchist movement: ‘Working-class theoreticians who express and formulate theories are totally ignored as of no consequence: what they say is attributed to the next available “Intellectual”.’ [3] Albert was sceptical of both academic methodology: ‘“Research”’ often means looking up dated reference books, and passing it off as knowledge.’ [4] and also their motivation: ‘Anarchism has become fair game for those eager to climb on the academic gravy train’. [5] History, and the writing of history, was deeply political to Albert. ‘Many would like to filch the history of the Anarchist movement.’ [6] A shining example of this – and the ‘sectarian’ riposte – came in Black Flag‘s response to Keith Paton’s ‘Alternative Liberalism : in search of ideological neighbours’ suggesting Young Liberals adopt ‘non-violent’ anarchism. Paton wrote ‘“I’m not talking about the violent or destructive currents of anarchism or the anarchism that tail-ends Marxism and is obsessed with preventing the ‘emasculation’ (sic) of the revolution… We claim a long and largely honourable tradition: e.g. it was we anarchists whom the Bolsheviks first attacked in post-revolutionary Russia, April 1918; e.g. the social creativity of the anarchist influenced workers and peasants in Spain in 1936-37, before snuffed out by the troops of right and left; May '68 to some extent[…]” Black Flag responded ‘Humbug! “We anarchists” whom the Bolsheviks attacked, “we anarchists” who fought in Spain, and struggled ever since – what have “we” to do with you? Or are you pretending that it was “Peace News” types that fought in Russia and Spain? What with, bunches of posies?’ [7] Albert pointed out the positive value of history – and its contested nature – in his review of British syndicalism by Bob Holton: ‘The histories of whole peoples were wiped out for precisely the same reason that the history of the working class movement in recent times is wiped out: it does not suit the conquerors for it to be known, because traditions keep alive the spirit of revolt.’ [8] The study of anarchism has ballooned since Albert’s death. Much solid history has been written and, importantly, published (not all of it by academics). Those of us who work on the history of the anarchist movement – a history from below if ever there was one – will keep digging. If we move on from Albert’s anecdotal approach to history, we would do well not to forget his scepticism. It would be unfortunate to leave history (or theory) to the ‘experts’ only to find ourselves lamenting, like the ‘uncontrollable’ from the Iron Column, ‘maybe we have failed to make ourselves understood’. [9] Notes 1, See ‘The Kate Sharpley Library Then, Now and Next: An Interview with Barry Pateman’ KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 63-64, October 2010 http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/0vt50w 2, Describing Cuddon’s Cosmopolitan Review, in chapter 12, pages 182-3 of I couldn’t paint golden angels (1996) http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/ngf32q 3, Albert Meltzer ‘Only a few intellectuals’ Black Flag vol.3, no.19 page 7 (April 1975) 4, Albert Meltzer I couldn’t paint golden angels chapter 9, page 166 http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/6djj4k 5, Albert Meltzer Anarchism: arguments for and against, 2nd edition (2000), page 18. 6, Albert Meltzer ‘What is the anarchist movement?’ Black Flag vol.7, no.7 page 36 (Autumn 1984) 7, Anonymous but probably Albert Meltzer ‘Roon ‘n’ aboot : Keith Paton knew my father’ Black Flag vol.4, no.13 page 4 (1977) 8, Cienfuegos Press Anarchist Review no.2 page 16 (1977) 9, An uncontrollable from the Iron Column, ‘The Iron Column, militarisation and the revolutionary future of Spain’ [AKA A day mournful and overcast] in Abel Paz The story of the Iron Column (2011) page 188. From KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 76, October 2013 |
Front pageThe party is haunting us again [Colombia] Declaración Constitutiva de Acción Libertaria Estudiantil Flora Tristán: precursora del feminismo y de la emancipación proletaria Bil'in - 10 years of persistent joint struggle In solidarity with the NO TAV struggle Wave of arrests in Ireland as state tries to break water charges movement Não se intimidar, não desmobilizar! Toda nossa solidariedade ao companheiro Vicente! After the election of Syriza in Greece - Power is not in Parliament [Chile] Movimiento Estudiantil: ¿En dónde debemos enfocar nuestros esfuerzos? México en llamas: raíces y perspectivas de una lucha que avanza y la crisis de un sistema político No to Golden Dawn in Australia! Abusos y arbitrariedad - retención de JOSÉ A. GUTIÉRREZ, en el bajo Caguán, Caquetá Could a Revolution Happen in the US? An Anarchist Communist Reply to ‘Rojava: An Anarcho-Syndicalist Perspective’ In the Rubble of US Imperialism Elementos da Conjuntura Eleitoral 2014 The experiment of West Kurdistan (Syrian Kurdistan) has proved that people can make changes [Chile] EL FTEM promueve una serie de “jornadas de debate sindical” Ukraine: Interview with a Donetsk anarchist Prisões e mais criminalização marcam o final da Copa do Mundo no Brasil Ireland / Britain | History of anarchism | en Thu 02 Apr, 01:36 Anarchism In Action: The WSM Is 25 17:08 Mon 07 Sep 4 comments The Workers Solidarity Movement is twenty-five years old this autumn. A quarter of a century ago anarchists in Ireland came together to establish an organisation to promote and fight for our ideas. No Wash protest ends - Hunger strike Begins! (1981) 02:23 Sun 06 May 0 comments The WSM has recently added 6 PDF's of anarchist publications from Ireland or about Ireland of the period from 1970 to 1983 (WSM was founded 1984). Today we make available an article published by the Belfast anarchist paper Outta Control written at the start of the Hunger Strike. The Third History – What Happened To Captain Jack White’s papers? 23:04 Wed 18 Apr 2 comments “The Burning” – PDF here– is a full length play written about the circumstances surrounding the destruction Captain Jack White’s papers following his death in Broughshane, Co. Antrim in 1946. White, as many people will know, was one of the more well known figures in Irish history that identified with anarchism. The only son of British Boer War hero, Sir George Stuart White (“The Hero Of Ladysmith”), he was assured a bright future in the upper echelons of the British military until his conscience intervened and he resigned his commission. John Taylor Caldwell - seaman and anarchist - 1911-2007 22:59 Tue 23 Jan 0 comments The Kate Sharpley Library are sad to report the death of John Taylor Caldwell, veteran Glasgow anarchist and comrade and biographer of Guy Aldred. Anarchist History documentaries on DVD 03:41 Sun 25 Sep 1 comments Two BBC documentaries on the Angry Brigade (1974) and 'Persons Unknown' trial (1980) are now available on one DVD from Christiebooks. Belfast Anarchist Group and the long march to Derry (1969) Jun 14 0 comments There is a myth about John McGuffin carrying the Belfast Anarchist Group‘s banner singlehanded on the Belfast to Derry civil rights march organised by Peoples Democracy in January 1969. Dublin Anarchist Group, May Day 1978 Apr 30 0 comments First leaflet from the Dublin Anarchist Group Whatever Happened to the Anarchist Workers Group? Mar 30 5 comments For many years the experience of the Anarchist Workers Group in Britain was used to smear ‘platformists’ as some sort of authoritarian tapeworm within the body of anarchism. It was claimed that our politics leads people out of anarchism and into Leninism. 40 years of British anarchism Nov 15 2 comments Nick Heath reflects on his experiences in the UK anarchist movement since the 1960s, and the lessons on organisation and politics he finds valid for anarchists today. From primitive to libertarian communism Jun 16 0 comments Communism, to many people, is a dirty word. Communism has been associated with Russia, a country which, in fact, had as its social system, not communism or socialism, but a particularly vicious and totalitarian form of State capitalism. I shall discuss, the system of Primitive Communism and then the ideas and theories of Utopian Communism, Authoritarian Communism and, lastly, Libertarian Communism more >>The Third History – What Happened To Captain Jack White’s papers? Apr 18 WSM - personal capacity 2 comments “The Burning” – PDF here– is a full length play written about the circumstances surrounding the destruction Captain Jack White’s papers following his death in Broughshane, Co. Antrim in 1946. White, as many people will know, was one of the more well known figures in Irish history that identified with anarchism. The only son of British Boer War hero, Sir George Stuart White (“The Hero Of Ladysmith”), he was assured a bright future in the upper echelons of the British military until his conscience intervened and he resigned his commission. Anarchist History documentaries on DVD Sep 25 KSL 1 comments Two BBC documentaries on the Angry Brigade (1974) and 'Persons Unknown' trial (1980) are now available on one DVD from Christiebooks. |