John Boehner

John Boehner’s blues

He says the president picked a "false fight" on student loans. Is he trying to throw the youth vote to the Dems? VIDEO

John Boehner (Credit: AP/Charles Dharapak)

If House Speaker John Boehner didn’t exist, the Democratic National Committee would be wishing desperately for someone just like him. On Thursday he became the point man opposing what he called President Obama’s “fake fight” to keep federal student loan rates from doubling. Boehner also questioned why the president was traveling the country talking to college students about the issue, calling it “pathetic” and “beneath the dignity of the White House.”

So not only does Boehner call minimizing student loan debt a “fake fight,” he mocks the relevance of young people to the political process by saying that addressing them, and the issue, is “beneath the dignity of the White House.” I’ve been worried about whether young people will turn out this November the way they did in 2008. But with Boehner in the spotlight talking about these issues, things are looking better on that score.

Of course, the House Republicans voted to keep the 6.8 percent loan rate intact in the Ryan budget. Now that they see the politics of the moment – weathervane Mitt Romney has reversed himself yet again and now wants to keep the rate at 3.4 percent – they’re jumping on the bandwagon. But they want to fund the rate reduction by cutting healthcare prevention programs. That’s GOP family values for you: OK, College Student, you can have your subsidized loan, but your little brother can’t get immunized and Mom will have to skip her breast cancer screening to pay for it.

The Republicans are incredible hypocrites on the issue. I’m glad the president has joined the fight. He’s now regularly talking about the fact that student loan debt is bigger than credit card debt in this country, which is a scandal.

But I think Obama and the Democrats must do more to reduce student loan debt and make college affordable. I support the loan-rate subsidy, for now, but it’s not a long-term solution (the 3.4 rate applies to money borrowed in 2011 and the deal on the table would extend the subsidy only another year.) I’d rather see taxpayer money, at the federal, state and local level, go directly into funding college tuition and college expansion than continue to encourage student debt – even at a lower interest rate. That’s not a realistic hope for this Congress, but we need to be talking about it, and soon.

Make no mistake: President Obama’s 2010 reform of the student loan system, ending the government’s guarantee and subsidy of private student loans so banks could make a no-risk profit, was more consequential than the extension of the lower loan rate. This is neither a “false fight” nor “beneath the dignity of the White House,” but there are bigger issues at stake than we’re debating right now.

I talked about Boehner’s silly student loan gambit on MSNBC’s “The Ed Show” Thursday night:

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Joan Walsh

Joan Walsh is Salon's editor at large.

A blue Christmas for John Boehner

President Obama's poll numbers rise as he fights for jobs while the House speaker winds up hostage to the Tea Party

President Barack Obama and House Speaker John Boehner (Credit: Reuters/AP)

President Obama’s poll numbers have been climbing steadily since he stopped compromising in search of a “grand bargain” deficit deal during the summer, and began fighting for jobs. They dropped much of the summer as he struggled to get a deal. At one point, polls showed that a third of independents, and most Democratic-leaning independents, wanted Obama to fight Republicans harder.

He got the message, and it’s been good news politically ever since. His strong numbers in the two most recent CNN and ABC/Washington Post polls prove that more Americans realize that it’s Republicans who are playing politics with the economy, and who are exclusively serving the interests of the top 1 percent. The climb in Obama’s numbers is particularly noteworthy among middle-class and self-described independent voters. Voters now trust the president more than the GOP not only on the issue of jobs, but taxes as well.

Even white men without a college degree, who have been one of the toughest groups for this president to win over, give him higher ratings than they have all year. More than 40 percent approve of the job he’s doing, and that number is higher than the share of that demographic group who voted for Obama in 2008. Early this year, only 22 percent of that group approved of the president’s job performance, according to a National Journal/Pew Research Center poll.

I’ve written before about the need to move beyond the charge of racism when analyzing the political views of white working-class and non-college-educated voters. (They aren’t precisely the same thing, but they’re often pretty close.) No doubt racism is part of the president’s difficulty with this demographic group, but that’s not the whole story, and it’s both incorrect and divisive to insist that’s the main explanation. The volatility in this group’s views of the president reflects its economic vulnerability at least as much as racial or cultural discomfort, and Obama shouldn’t give up on them when shaping his 2012 pitch. He may not win a majority, but he shouldn’t settle for the 65-35 drubbing Democrats took in 2010. Democrats are fighting for the working and middle class now.

It’s also good news that senior citizens are happier with the president. Of course, John McCain won that group in 2008, and a Republican may win white seniors again in 2012. But Obama’s climbing approval rating with seniors – they’re now about evenly divided between approval and disapproval – ought to show the importance of standing up for Social Security and Medicare, and the political and moral dangers in continuing to crusade for a deficit “grand bargain” that cuts either program.  Let’s hope the president leaves those ideas behind in 2011.

Obama’s stern, sober remarks chiding House GOP radicals indicate he knows he has a winning strategy. Unlike last summer, there was no talk about one last compromise. It takes two parties to compromise, and Obama is done compromising with himself.

Woe is John Boehner. What do you call a leader who can’t lead? Mr. Speaker, apparently. He’ll have a blue Christmas, for sure.  Unfortunately, so will struggling Americans if there isn’t a last-minute deal to extend the payroll tax cuts. But Democrats are absolutely right to put an end to compromise at this point. I’ll be talking about all these developments on MSNBC’s “Politics Nation” with Rev. Al Sharpton at 6 ET.

Continue Reading Close
Joan Walsh

Joan Walsh is Salon's editor at large.

Keystone pipeline as GOP poison pill

Desperate Republican seeks to link pipeline approval to the payroll tax cut extension

Pipeline politics(Credit: Reuters/Stephen Lam)

Ever since the Obama administration announced it would delay its final decision on the controversial Keystone XL pipeline until 2013, Republicans in Congress have been plotting ways to get around the lengthier review process ordered by the president, which would include a rigorous assessment of health and environmental impacts by the State Department.

Last Wednesday, a group of Republican senators, including Nebraska Sen. Mike Johanns, co-sponsored a bill that would fast-track the pipeline, requiring President Obama to issue a decision on the pipeline within the next 60 days and precluding a more in-depth review of its impacts. Now, Nebraska Rep. Lee Terry, with support from House Speaker John Boehner, is seeking to attach a provision that would force a quick decision on the pipeline to a bill designed to extend unemployment benefits and payroll tax cuts, which are currently set to expire Jan. 1 of next year.

The proposal to extend unemployment benefits and the payroll tax cut has divided the Republican Party, with some arguing that the measures are too costly and will create little economic benefit, while others are reluctant to oppose measures that would provide relief to tens of millions of American workers. Sensing advantage, President Obama and the Democrats are pressing hard for approval of the extension of the benefits and the payroll tax cut.

Boehner recently described his payroll tax proposal as turning “chicken shit into chicken salad,” indicating that he’s going to make Democrats pay for any legislative victory. He knows that a bill proposing to hasten the Keystone review process would never make it through Congress on its own, and is hoping to keep the pipeline’s adversaries from scuttling the proposal by attaching the quick review to popular legislation that Democrats are determined to pass.

Terry’s proposal would transfer decision-making authority from the State Department to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) and would require FERC to issue a ruling on the pipeline almost immediately, within 30 days of receiving a permit application — despite the fact that, as George Zornick points out, “FERC has not been involved in the Keystone process whatsoever,” and has no prior experience with similar projects.

Environmental groups claim the strategy is simply an attempt to evade a public debate about the pipeline: Environmental leader Bill McKibben described the negotiations as going on “behind closed doors in money-filled rooms.” Kim Huynh, a dirty fuels campaigner at Friends of the Earth, called the House GOP strategy an attempt to slip the Keystone decision “under the radar of the U.S. public, limiting the ability for real debate.”

While Huynh called the bill a “really long shot” for congressional approval, Friends of the Earth and other environmental groups have mobilized to block it with a petition signed by a hundred thousand people asking Senate Majority leader Harry Reid and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi not to give in to Republican pressure. Becky Bond, the political director of CREDO Action,  which organized the petition, said that the group is only asking that Democrats stick to their guns, saying that people are “sick of being thrown under the bus to appease Republicans” in what she described as a “game of chicken” between the two parties.

In an open letter to Reid, a group of five Democratic senators, including Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I., Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., Ron Wyden, D-Ore., and Frank Lautenberg, D-N.J., called the attempt to seek legislative go-ahead for the pipeline “completely inappropriate,” warning that removing the State Department from the process of making decisions about cross-border projects would “set a troubling precedent.” After meeting with Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper on Wednesday afternoon, Obama said, “Any effort to try to tie Keystone to the payroll tax cut, I will reject.”

Still, while this particular attempt to get the Keystone pipeline approved is unlikely to succeed, it is only one of several environment-related riders the GOP is seeking to sneak into various pieces of upcoming spending legislation, including proposals that would block the EPA from regulating agricultural runoff and limiting toxic air pollution from cement kilns.

Continue Reading Close

Alyssa Battistoni writes about the environment and politics from Seattle.

John Boehner totally owned Barack Obama on the phone, according to Boehner

House Speaker releases amusingly self-congratulatory account of phone call with the president to the press

House Speaker John Boehner (Credit: AP/J. Scott Applewhite)

John Boehner wants everyone to know that he gave the president what-for yesterday. Boehner is a fairly ineffectual House Speaker who has on multiple occasions held important votes that he has lost embarrassingly. But while he may not be able to control his caucus, he can certainly let everyone know that he yelled at Barack Obama. That’s why the Speaker’s office released “an unusually detailed account” of his phone conversation with the president to the press.

The president had called Boehner to congratulate him on passing those pointless trade agreements. But Boehner wanted to talk about how Obama had accused the GOP of not having a jobs plan. That won’t fly with hard-charging House Speaker John Boehner! According to Boehner’s summary of how cool and in control he was on the phone, Boehner had no time for these congratulations. “I want to make sure you have all the facts,” Boehner said, according to Boehner:

“The speaker told the president that when he sent his jobs plan to the Hill, Republicans pledged to give it consideration, and have done so,” the release stated. “The president was reminded of a memo written by GOP leaders outlining the specific areas where they believe common ground can be found. The Speaker also noted that a number of the president’s ideas have already been acted on in the House, including a veterans hiring bill, trade agreements, and a three percent withholding bill approved by the Ways & Means Committee today that will be considered on the House floor this month.”

According to Boehner’s account of the call, Boehner then put on sunglasses and got on a motorcycle. Also he was smoking the whole time, coolly. Then Boehner continued not holding votes on anything important while Eric Cantor repeatedly and blatantly undermined him to the press and the most conservative members of their caucus.

Continue Reading Close
Alex Pareene

Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene

www.salon.com/topic/john_boehner/index.html
TopLeft