For Lefties too Stubborn to Quit
School league tables? 08:03 Wed Jan 25, 2012 | WorldbyStorm
New Broad-Based ?Campaign Against Austerity Treaty? Launches Call for EU Referendum 19:30 Tue Jan 24, 2012 | Garibaldy
Matt Lygate ? Scottish Socialist Republican 09:26 Tue Jan 24, 2012 | WorldbyStorm
Mixing messages on the property market? 07:16 Tue Jan 24, 2012 | WorldbyStorm
Talking about your ULA? 00:24 Tue Jan 24, 2012 | WorldbyStorm Cedar Lounge >>
It's a group blog. What more do you need to know?
VACANT HOUSING IN IRELAND AND SOCIAL HOUSING NEEDS - A COMPARISON 12:43 Mon Jan 23, 2012
?A BOMB WILL GO OFF IN DUBLIN, NOT IN FRANKFURT, BECAUSE OF THE REASONS I?VE OUTLINED? 23:50 Sun Jan 22, 2012
NAMA WINE LAKE : JUST ANOTHER RIGHT-WING NUTTER 23:14 Sat Jan 21, 2012
GERY LAWLESS, 1936-2012 15:58 Sat Jan 21, 2012
?269,000 FOR A HOUSE IN AN UNFIT FOR PURPOSE ESTATE 15:04 Sat Jan 21, 2012 Dublin Opinion >>
Joined up thinking for the Irish Left
Normalising Apartheid: The Israeli Parliamentary Visit to Ireland Tue Jan 24, 2012 22:45 | Kevin Squires
Michael Taft talks to Doug Henwood of Left Business Observer about the Irish Eco... Tue Jan 24, 2012 16:28 | Donagh
Tin Whistles and Mpouzoukia Tue Jan 24, 2012 12:28 | Michael Taft
What are bankers doing inside EU summits? | Corporate Europe Observatory Mon Jan 23, 2012 18:08 | Donagh
Halt to Anglo Debt Re-Payments Would Not ?Set off Bomb? Mon Jan 23, 2012 16:41 | Donagh Irish Left Review >>
A shot at bias in the media
The web's political rainbow Wed Dec 07, 2011 09:47
The Forgotten Constituency: The Majority and The Irish Economic Crisis Fri Mar 11, 2011 11:49
A curse on the zombie establishment Tue Sep 21, 2010 15:11
'Officials say', 'officials say', 'according to an official' Tue Jul 27, 2010 17:05
'The false reality of news journalism' Fri Jul 02, 2010 13:15 MediaBite >>
|
Marlborough Street bridge plan looks increasingly absurd amid decimated city centre traffic levels
dublin |
environment |
opinion/analysis
Tuesday January 24, 2012 11:32 by Vincent Byrne
![Report this post to the editors Report this post to the editors](/web/20120125110615im_/http://www.indymedia.ie/graphics/report.gif)
Dublin is still reeling from its boom period and the cacophony of high-flown plans it threw up. Now that it's all over, how do the various projects stand up?
![Click on image to see full-sized version Overhead view of Dublin City Council’s planned “public transport priority” bridge at Marlborough Street – Hawkins Street.](/web/20120125110615im_/http://www.indymedia.ie/cache/imagecache/local/attachments/jan2012/460_0___30_0_0_0_0_0_av2.jpg) Overhead view of Dublin City Council’s planned “public transport priority” bridge at Marlborough Street – Hawkins Street.
Dublin is still reeling from its boom period and the cacophony of high-flown plans it threw up. Now that it's all over, how do the various projects stand up?
One boom-era plan that seems set to proceed is Dublin City Council's building of a “public transport priority” bridge over the Liffey between Marlborough Street and Hawkins Street.
Conceived as a relief bridge while Metro North was under construction at adjacent O’Connell Bridge, it would later accommodate a southbound line of the city-centre Luas link, plus buses and taxis.
Metro North is more or less cancelled, and the Luas link, while pencilled in to proceed in 2015, has yet to secure funding of an estimated €170 million.
The location of the new bridge so close to O’Connell Bridge was always problematic, but it was accepted by city stakeholders in the context of plansat the time, and passed through the planning system with little or no objection.
But now, with the dramatic decline in city-centre traffic levels over the past three or four years, and changes to other plans, the Marlborough Street – Hawkins Street bridge is becoming an increasingly absurd idea.
It will effectively provide a broad new multi-lane road bridge a few metres to the east of the widest bridge in the country and one of the widest of its kind in the world.
The bridge has no real circulation gain, as it simply leaves and enters the same traffic circulation system that already exists in the area, serving only to bypass O’Connell Bridge.
Nor is the bridge needed by Luas - the wide streets handed down to us by the Georgian planners of the 18th century give ample space along O'Connell Street and Westmoreland Street for a Luas line travelling in eachdirection, plus vehicle, cycle lane and footpath space.
When and if the Luas link eventually comes to be constructed, the obvious route to take (and despite the results of ‘route selection’ processes) is that of the original alignment with both directions running along O’Connell Street, O’Connell Bridge and Westmoreland Street, not least for the reduced costs of keeping the two lines together.
The city centre streets and bridges are the product of the great period of classical urban planning in the 18th century. Bridges on the Liffey were built at a consistent distance from each other, and the river and streets led to views of carefully positioned setpiece buildings.
The regular spacing of bridges along the Liffey was observed for hundreds of years, until 2003 when James Joyce Bridge was built in-between two older bridges near Queen Street. The disorienting, incoherent effect of bridges built close to one another here is plain for all to see.
James Joyce Bridge makes no sense in its location, although it was in fact a legacy of Dublin Corporation's insane 1960s road plans for central Dublin and should arguably have been shelved when the body of those plans were shelved in the 1980s.
Likewise, combined factors today including the recession, the opening of the Samuel Beckett relief bridge in the docklands and the huge increase in the popularity of cycling arising from the Cycle to Work and bike rental schemes have radically changed traffic conditions in the centre over past the past couple of years, and future plans provide for further reduction of traffic.
The justification for the Marlborough Street – Hawkins Street bridge is now extremely shaky and we should face up to it. It is a product of the distorted, addled period that was the economic boom in Dublin, and its unprecedented pressures.
The minor circulation gain in linking Marlborough Street and Hawkins Street will be massively outweighed by its impact on the plan of one of Europe’s great classical cities.
Proceeding with the bridge now will repeat the town-planning mistake of James Joyce Bridge on a grand scale and will leave another stain on the record of Dublin City Council.
It is not too late to reconsider. The site has been hoarded off since the New Year but no construction work has begun. A review of the bridge should now be undertaken by the government.
|