British Marxists, Jews and world war two: response to Colin Shindler

Posted on Sunday 8 January, 2012
Filed Under History, The left | 44 Comments

 


SOAS professor Colin Shindler can’t quite bring himself openly to state that British Marxists would have collaborated with the Wehrmacht had Germany invaded Britain in 1940. So he implies it instead, resorting to the transparently shoddy device of putting a question mark after each de facto accusation contained in his essay for the Jewish Chronicle last week.

His basic thesis – doubtless to be expanded in the book he publishes next month – is that despite over-representation of Jews in revolutionary movements in the first half of the last century, the left would have prevaricated in the fight against fascism and was at best indifferent to the fate of European Jewry.

Read more

A letter to Occupy London

Posted on Sunday 8 January, 2012
Filed Under Anti-capitalism | 1 Comment

 


BEING the wrong side of 50, I was secretly quite chuffed when The Occupied Times of London, a publication produced at the St Paul’s and Finsbury Square camps by the Indy Media team, asked me to write a piece for them. You can read my contribution here.

The class politics of standardised mortality rates

Posted on Thursday 5 January, 2012
Filed Under Society | 26 Comments

 


BRYNCETHIN? It’s some village near Bridgend, apparently. Never heard of it until this morning, to be honest. Wouldn’t like to guess as to how you pronounce the name.

However, the place finds itself in the news this morning, after data released to parliament revealed that the age-adjusted death rate per nominal 100,000 people is 1,499. That compares with 1,452 in Botswana and 1,427 in Rwanda.

This could just be a statistical quirk. After all, Bryncethin doesn’t have 100,000 people. There are only some 1,300 residents. Maybe 2009 was just an unlucky year for a couple of the locals.

But as the full excel spreadsheet reveals, there are over 100 wards in England and Wales where the death rate is more than double the 492 per 100,000 seen in the UK as a whole, and they are heavily concentrated in former industrial areas.

Read more

Has the Metropolitan Police really changed?

Posted on Wednesday 4 January, 2012
Filed Under Law, Society | 20 Comments

 


SIR William Macpherson’s famous observation back in 1999 that the Metropolitan Police was ‘institutionally racist’ did not come as any particular revelation to me. That is because the Met is the closest thing I have to a family business.

My grandfather and two uncles were all London coppers in decades gone by, and there have been times when I have defended their career choices against the sneers of the bien pensant.

Yes, the uncles were at Grunwick, deployed to get strikebreakers through the picket lines. Had they not retired before 1984-85 arrived, they would doubtless have repeated the performance on one or more northern coalfield.

So what should I have done? Approach them with a class appeal based on Althusser’s analysis of the objective function of the repressive state apparatus, or something? These were hardly the kind of blokes to get their heads round the finer points of French structuralist Marxism.

Read more

Psycho Stapleton probably didn’t have a gun licence

Posted on Tuesday 3 January, 2012
Filed Under Society | 24 Comments

 


ANYONE who can calmly give his name as ‘Psycho’ when facing murder charges in a magistrates’ court is unlikely to be too diligent in his compliance with state stipulations for the possession of firearms.

So while this is pure guesswork on my part, it may well be that Kieran Stapleton did not have a licence for the weapon he allegedly used to kill Anuj Bidve on Boxing Day.

Gun control is currently in the headlines following the tragic events in Peterlee on New Year’s Day, which saw depressed taxi driver Michael Atherton slay his partner and two members of her family before shooting himself.

Atherton, of course, was lawfully able to keep six weapons, despite having his licence reviewed in 2008 after threatening to harm himself.

Read more

Political predictions for 2012: open thread

Posted on Sunday 1 January, 2012
Filed Under Blogging, Politics | 31 Comments

 


HAPPY New Year, readers. Rather then write anything substantial myself today – I am still feeling a tad delicate after somewhat exceeding government drink unit guidelines last night, to be honest – I will instead open the comments box for any reflections people may have on likely developments in the year ahead.

Here at home, tensions seem to be growing within the Coalition. How do you assess its stability? Meanwhile, Ed Miliband is coming in for increasing stick from Blairite irreconcilables. What are the chances of a leadership challenge in the coming 12 months? Is Scotland on an exit trajectory from the United Kingdom? I am about to read up on Northern Ireland, but I would be interested in observations from anybody who follows events there more closely than I do. And let’s not leave Wales out of the picture.

Turning away from Westminster, Holyrood, Stormont and the Senedd, what about the state of the class struggle? Are we on the brink of a serious fightback against austerity, or does the recent ’heads of agreement’ deal on pensions signal that the unions have thrown in the towel? What about other countries? Does the eurozone crisis carry within it the potential for major radicalisation in Greece or Italy? Or could it be that the right will benefit rather than the left?

Elsewhere, what do you think about the outlook for the Middle East? Can the Egyptian revolution be taken a step further, and what forces would come out on top? Will we see another year of stalemate on the Israel/Palestine question? Is Syria shaping up to be another Libya, or can Assad keep the lid on the situation? And what if Iran does make good on its threat to close off the Strait of Hormuz?

What about other flashpoints around the world? Can Putin pull off a return to the Russian presidency? Will the tensions between Muslims and Christians in Nigeria deteriorate further? Can Pakistan hold together? Should we fear a hard landing for the Chinese economy?

Your thoughts on these and any other topics that come to mind, ladies and gentlemen. Now, where did I put those sodding aspirins?

What exactly is London’s problem with Liverpool?

Posted on Friday 30 December, 2011
Filed Under Conservative Party, Politics | 37 Comments

 


LONDON has a Conservative mayor who famously accused Liverpool of displaying a ‘deeply unattractive psyche’, and even of ‘wallowing in its victim status’. But as a cockney myself, I reckon scousers can be forgiven for feeling that little bit chippy.

Nor is Boris Johnson’s attitude any novelty within his party, as is demonstrated by today’s revelation that back in 1981, top Tories Geoffrey Howe and Sir Keith Joseph advised Margaret Thatcher to abandon that beastly city altogether.

Howe actually employed the expression ‘managed decline’, before duplicitously warning everyone else against using such a scandalous locution in the public’s earshot. Thanks to the 30 year rule, the gaffe is now public. Be sure your sin will find you out.

Despite the reputation Liverpool picked up for radicalism after Militant secured control of the local authority in the year that followed Howe’s overly frank memo, until the 1950s it was just about the only working class conurbation in this country to return mainly Conservative MPs to Westminster, thanks largely to religious sectarianism imported from the other side of the Irish Sea.

Read more

A tax on the drinking classes

Posted on Thursday 29 December, 2011
Filed Under Conservative Party, Politics | 24 Comments

 


I AM not a champagne socialist. But that is solely because I do not actually like the stuff. Otherwise, I fully endorse the maxim of the late Christopher Hitchens that cheap booze is a false economy. Give me Glenmorangie, or give me death.

It is a pretty fair bet that David Cameron thinks along the same lines as the Hitch. The assumption has to be that £4.15 Tesco’s red has not been the vino da tavola of choice among the Chipping Norton set this festive season. There is a reason why fancy schmancy wine from Bordeaux is called Cru Bourgeois and not Cru Prolétarienne.

Given that so few posh folk are on the old purple tin or sit on street corners swigging White Lightning poorly concealed in a brown paper bag , the policy of imposing a minimum price per unit of alcohol will hurt only the less affluent, while not having any impact whatsoever on those of us with more upmarket tastes.

It is almost as if the government wanted to send the message that it is perfectly OK to contract cirrhosis of the liver, so long as a chap has the decency to inflict the illness on himself with a decent single malt rather than supermarket own brand blended scotch.

Read more

Life on Labour?

Posted on Tuesday 27 December, 2011
Filed Under Labour Left, Labour Party | 30 Comments

 


DESPITE the failure of Russia’s latest space probe, scientists are rightly determined to continue their search for life on Mars. The way things are going right now, it looks like that quest will reach fruition long before anyone ever discovers signs of life in the Labour Party.

It’s not that I saw the defeat of New Labour at the ballot box last year as a prelude to a rerun of the Bennite years. Apart from anything else, the weight of the left both inside and outside Labour is insufficient to permit stuff like that. To revamp a period slogan, it’s never again for “never again”.

But as a Labour Party member myself, my expectation was that some sort of internal discussion over the way Labour governed for 13 years would open up. Perhaps some leading figures would finally give voice some of the criticisms they had been bottling up while the Thought Police held sway throughout Oceania.

Even the re-emergence of a distinctly social democratic current would mark a step forward of sorts, especially if it were open to dialogue with Marxism. But more than 18 months after the return of the ConDems, nobody on the left has even properly attempted a balance sheet of the 1997-2010 experience and asked what lessons should have been learned.

Read the rest here.

 

Thatcher’s funeral: you mourn if you want to

Posted on Friday 23 December, 2011
Filed Under Conservative Party | 57 Comments

 


PERHAPS the most inane remark ever uttered by any leading New Labour figure - invidious though it is to select just one, of course – is Peter Mandelson’s vapid contention that ‘we are all Thatcherites now’. Some of us never were, and never will be.

Such abject ideological capitulation to the ideas Labour was created to stand against demonstates a certain arrogant incomprehension on the political right, a category into which Mandelson clearly falls. Admiration for Margaret Thatcher is far from universal.

The former prime minister, whose life is celebrated in an impending biopic, is now in frail health, and plans are already underway to mark her passing.

The announcement of her death, whenever it comes, will no doubt provoke endless days of media coverage celebrating her ‘greatness’, a quality that ‘even her opponents came to recognise’, or so we shall be told. For those of us who were involved in the labour movement in 1980s, such a conclusion will not readily be conceded.

Read more

keep looking »