Sometimes it is difficult to keep track of all of the various Guided by Voices songs on EPs, singles and one-offs. I listen to the band’s albums more than anything, so weeks or months can go by without my hearing certain songs.
That’s the reason why I was puzzled when I saw the song “Break Even” on the first couple of set lists from the band’s just-launched reunion tour. “What’s that?” I said to myself. I looked it up and found that it’s a later song on The Grand Hour EP. The band had announced it would play songs from four albums released during 1992-96, but obviously decided to be a bit more broad.
It’s a nice move to pull from a more obscure EP (they also play “Johnny Appleseed” from The Clown Prince of the Menthol Trailer EP), but I’m surprised this is what they chose. It’s a strange tune that has little of the melodicism and hooks of the songs that surround it (“Buzzards and Dreadful Crows” and “Hot Freaks” or “My Valuable Hunting Knife” in the first two sets). In a way, the more abrasive tone has more in common with Pollard’s latter-day work, particularly his Circus Devils music with Todd Tobias.
If nothing else, the choice is a nod to the most rabid of fans who know every song from the first note, and might bring attention to a forgotten chapter in the band’s back catalog. Plus, it’s a slab of psychedelia that obviously appeals to the band. No reason on this tour to play anything they don’t like.
It will be interesting to see if it remains in the set as the tour progresses.