Bleachgate – the British connection

Let me introduce you to Christian Pankhurst…

According to his Twitter profile, Christian is ‘about living from the heart, expanding awareness beyond the mind and helping people connect intimately’ but he also has an interesting sideline selling a so-called ‘miracle cure’ made of an industrial bleaching agent, sodium chlorite.

Sodium chlorite has a number of quite interesting uses. It’s used primarily in paper-making as a bleaching agent but it also turns up in very small amounts in some theraputic rinses, mouthwashes, toothpastes and gels and in some contact lens cleaning solutions. Under brand name ‘Oxine’, its also used to sanitise air conditioning systems and animal containment areas.

What it doesn’t do, if ingested by humans, is cure HIV, hepatitis, the H1N1 flu virus, common colds, acne, cancer or anything else for that matter. In fact, if you follow the instructions given for using this supposed miracle cure then what you are likely to experience is nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and symptoms of severe dehydration -

- and don’t just take my word for it, that’s also the view of the US Food and Drug Administration who, at the end of July, issued a safety alert warning consumers not to use this product.

I could write more about what has quickly come to be known to skeptics as ‘Bleachgate’ but for brevity’s sake, and to avoid repetition, you can pick up most of the gory details from Rhys Morgan, who kicked this whole story off with supplemental information and commentary from Zenbuffy and Cubik’s Rube, but for now I think its well worth giving Christian Pankhurst the benefit of a full once-over.

Pankhurst is what might reasonably be described as a ‘Quack’s quack’ and even goes so far as to describe himself, on his personal website, as ‘Dr Christian Pankhurst D.C’.

The letters ‘D.C.’ after his name indicate that he is a ‘Doctor of Chiropractic’ which, of course, means that he’s not really a doctor at all and certainly not a medical doctor. Actually, he’s not any kind of doctor, not even a doctor of chiropractic as his LinkedIn profile indicates that he only has a ‘Masters degree’ in backcracking from the Anglo European College of Chiropractic, which he gained in 2002, some twelve years after the AECC ceased to offer the American ‘Doctor of Chiropractic’ qualification.

Within a year of completing his training as a chiropractor, Pankhurst switched to a different but not less lucrative field of quackery, ‘life-coaching’, which is, today, his main line of business despite the fact that he appears not to possess any qualifications that might be relevant. Pankhurst actually describes himself as a ‘relationship consultant’ and ‘communication coach’ and states on his website that he ‘studied with some of the most well known leaders in the personal development industry’ – so well known, in fact, that he appears to be unable to name any of them on his site.

In fact, so far as can be ascertained, he appears to have become a ‘disciple’ of an American New-Age Guru, Neale Donald Walsch, who, so far as I can tell without polluting my brain any further, seems to peddle a fairly routine line in wholly derivative, bog standard Hippy dreck which he’s managed to flesh out a bit using the old ‘speaking to god‘ gambit. It’s a poor guru who can’t even get his Wikipedia entries straight but that a feat that Walsch and his followers have managed by including a section on ‘Parellels in other belief systems‘ which states that…

Walsch claims that he had never known most of these ideas before his revelatory experiences

…even though his main Wikipedia biography states that he was…

brought up as a Roman Catholic by a family who encouraged his quest for spiritual truth.

…as a result of which he…

studied The Bible, the Rig Veda and the Upanishads

Like I said, a quack’s quack.

Interestingly, in addition to his MMSEurope site, which peddles bleach to the UK, Pankhurst also has a site MMSAmerica.info which sells the same crap to the US although, in this case, part of the paper trail also leads back to a Devon-based firm of toolmakers, Pankhurst Trading Ltd, which is run by a David Pankhurst. On Ebay, MMSEurope states that it is a ‘division of Pankhurst Trading LTD’ and gives the Devon address of Pankhurst Trading Ltd as its main contact address, but with a Manchester (0161) phone number.

A reverse IP check also reveals two firther bleach peddling sites located on the same server as MMSEurope.com and MMSAmerica.info, MMSNederland.nl and MiracleMineralSolution.eu – the later maps to the same Dutch language site as MMSNederland – along with Pankhurst’s personal website.

Naturally, all of Pankhurst’s site include a compendious quack miranda warning

Disclaimer:

The seller is not a licensed doctor or healthcare practitioner and should not be regarded or contacted as such, and statements of ailment or disease support are not provided by the seller as it is illegal to do so. The Miracle Mineral Supplement (or MMS, Miracle Mineral Cure as it is commonly known) is a water purification product and is not an approved health care supplement, and therefore is not intended for human consumption. All information provided is for educational purposes only and is NOT to diagnose, prescribe, cure or treat any diseases, or replace the consultation and advice of a licensed healthcare practitioner. Any statements or testimonials anywhere on the website or links provided are individual cases and do not guarantee that you will get the same results. You agree that no responsibility or liability will be incurred to any person or entity with respect to any loss, damage or injury caused or alleged to be caused directly or indirectly by the information contained in this site. If you have a severe medical condition, please consult a licensed healthcare professional.

Note also; this website contains links to other websites operated by third parties. These links are provided for your convenience and reference only. The seller is not responsible for the content or products of any linked sites or the links contained therein.

However, while researching this article, I turned up a post on hubpages.com entitled ‘Jim Humble is going to Jail?‘ which sheds some interesting light on the provenence of Pankhurst’s disclaimer in the form of an email message that was apparently sent by Humble to his salespeople…

Agency is trying to take MMS off the market…

I just got a desperate letter from Jim Humble the discoverer of MMS stating that “sorry, but my name and my picture must be removed from all sites selling mms in any form. All of the jim humble approval stamps must be removed from every site selling mms.”

He further states, “This must happen immediately. Any time the attack comes if my approval is on any sales site that can be used to put me in jail. This is true in most countries as well as the united states, especially in Europe. Please comply with this. It is important. This must be done immediately. Taking my name off of your site will also keep you out of jail.

“I appreciate your help in bringing mms to the world. Now is the time to change mms to nothing but water purification drops. My sites will remain in place so that people can use them. They don’t lead people to other sales sites. When the time comes the authorities must see nothing but mms water purification drops. We will have to depend upon my book, radio, TV, you tube, and other internet articles to tell what mms really is.

“One other point, anywhere on your site where the word supplement is used it should be changed to the word “solution”, the reason for that is the FDA objects to the word supplement, that begins to neutralize our sites. Is for your protection.” End of announcement!

That all seems to suggest both that Humble, the creator of the MMS scam, is fully aware of what he’s doing and that Pankhurst is likely to have received this particular email, hence the references to water purification tablets.

In any case, enjoy Pankhurst while you can as if his scam sites start to disappear, that’ll likely be because Trading Standards have paid him a visit.

3 Comments
It’s Tabloid Correctness Gone Mad!

It’s been less than a week since Tim launch ‘Operation Cloaca‘ and already it seems we have an urgent need to come up with a suitable collective noun for multiple cloacas as no less than four newspapers – The Daily Mail, Express, Star, and the increasingly comic-like Daily Telegraph – have all run the same bullshit story.

Council forces schools to rearrange exams

- Continue Reading...

4 Comments
Depression, Homeopathy and Prozac

It hasn’t taken Tory MP David Tredinnick long to start spitting out dubious EDM’s in defence of homeopathy.

The new parliament is only a little over a month old and he’s already tabled four such motions, including a generic attack on the British Medical Association and three EDMs flagging up  newly published research which purports to demonstrate that homeopathy may provide viable treatments… - Continue Reading...

3 Comments
Everybody Research the Holocaust Day

Last week’s ‘Everybody Draw Mohammed Day‘ generated a number of depressinging stupid responses; nowhere more so than in Pakistan where the government resorted to blocking access to Facebook, Youtube, Flickr and parts of Wikipedia in an effort to ‘protect’ its citizens from the heinous sight of several thousand photoshopped stick-men with word ‘Mohammed’  scrawled underneath.

Less than a week later, a… - Continue Reading...

One Comment
Strictly Come Quacking

To most people Fiona Phillips is just a former GMTV presenter who, on Strictly Come Dancing, demonstrated to the world that she has two left feet.

On the evidence of her latest column in the Mirror, she’s also a raging crank who makes piss poor excuses for quackery…

MMR doc’s just guilty of caring

Surprise, surprise, the doctor who highlighted a possible link between the

- Continue Reading...

6 Comments
Into the Valley of Death rode the seven-hundred

If the furore surrounding the hacking of a webmail server at UEA’s Climate Research Unit has achieved anything at all it’s been to push the issue of scientific probity and integrity firmly into the spotlight. By far the most damning, but still unproven, allegation levelled at the CRU’s scientists is that they deliberated distorted and manipulated the evidence to shore up AGW theory and, on… - Continue Reading...

8 Comments
Monty Pythons’ Life of O’Brien

Much has already been written on the subject of the first two oral evidence sessions in Science and Technology Committee’s investigation of  homeopathy, more than enough, in fact, to allow me to point you in the direction of a couple of articles by Ben Goldacre and Skepticat’s excellent commentary and let you take it from there.

What’s just as… - Continue Reading...

2 Comments
ADE651 Fraudsters Astroturfing Here…

There is only one thing I enjoy more than exposing junk-science scams and that exposing junk-science scams where the perpetrator is dumb enough to try it on.

This morning, three comments were posted on my recent exposé of the ‘dowsing for explosives’ scam in the space of 20 minutes, all purporting to be from satisfied users of the ADE651 dowsing rod.

‘Frank’ claims… - Continue Reading...

6 Comments
EmoTrance: The New Name for Bullshit

I learned a new word this week – EmoTrance.

EmoTrance is the new name for bullshit.

In the last week, its received no less than two articles worth of coverage in The Times’ educational supplements; one, a vomit inducing piece of brainless advertorial by Adi Bloom, an arts correspondent with a taste for ‘kitsch’ – i.e. fucking gullible –… - Continue Reading...

8 Comments
Numbers

An adventure into drugs policy, risk and mortality statistics…

[youtube width="560" height="340"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wZAai1E5JmM[/youtube]

No Comments
Archives
Recent Comments
Recommended
Science/Skepticism
Politics
Ministry of Truth RSS 2.0
Ministry of Truth - Twitter
  • Why are Libdems so calm in the face of electoral meltdown? November 5, 2010
    This was originally written for the Guardian. Am cross-posting it here too. I don’t want to go all Margaret Thatcher on you, but it seems the Liberal Democrats will soon cease to be; they will expire. They will ring down the curtain and join the choir invisible. I may be exaggerating, but only slightly. On [...] […]
    Sunny Hundal
  • David Davis: ‘libertarian’ against striking November 5, 2010
    Too many of those directly engaged in industrial relations regard it as all a bit of a laugh. As a journalist who has covered numerous disputes ever since the 1980s, I know plenty of union officials and employer reps who get a kick out of showing what a clever clogs they can be across the negotiating table. A spot of brinkmanship here, a threat of some argy- […]
    Dave Osler
  • Muslims tell tabloids: put us on your front pages! November 5, 2010
    Minority Thought, 5CC and Anton Vowl all deal with the tabloids' curious sense of priorities when it came to the sentencing of Roshonara Choudhry, deciding that the antics of three mouth breathers in the public gallery were of far more importance than the culmination of a far more fascinating and worrying court case in their usual fine fashion. More of […]
    Septicisle
  • Chocolate or Sex? October 31, 2010
    Those of you on Twitter may already be familiar with Stephen Fry, that most eloquent of British celebrities. I'm afraid to report that he got into a spot of bother today over a comment he made... read more […]
    Unfriendly Atheist
  • Choose Life October 29, 2010
    A look at the latest round of anti-abortion campaigns For some reason, Christian anti-abortion groups have chosen the 43rd anniversary of the Abortion Act to launch their latest campaign. read more […]
    Tessera
  • The Druid Network October 23, 2010
    On September 21st, the Charity Commission published its decision in respect of The Druid Network’s application for charitable status. read more […]
    Jourdemayne