Latest Opinons on The Punch

Update 9:15PM: Appearing on Sky News this evening the crucial three independents Bob Katter, Rob Oakeshott and Tony Windsor say they still have not made up their minds over which party to support.  It continues.

Tasmanian independent Andrew Wilkie’s decision to side with Julia Gillard’s Labor Government is not surprising.

The intelligence officer turned Iraq war whistler blower was basically labelled a clear and present danger to national security by the Howard Government, formally had a fling with The Greens and now holds what is usually a safe Labor seat – hardly paints the picture of someone who would hand Government to the Coalition. Like the laughable attempt by Bob Brown to tell us the day after the election the Greens could side with any party, Wilkie’s decision ended what was a series of false flirtations with Tony Abbott.

But by revealing that Tony Abbott, like Dr Evil making an ambit claim, was willing to write a $1 billion cheque for Royal Hobart Hospital, Wilkie could have done more damage to Abbott than anything Treasury can come up with.

Latest 2 of 41 comments

 
  • Casablanca says:

    08:55pm | 02/09/10

    FYI Denison since 1903 has returned 11 members from the conservative side of politics and 7 from the ALP. Wilkie is the first Independent to win the seat. Wilkie was a member of the Young Liberals and then became a grown up Liberal Read more »

  • Dungla says:

    08:49pm | 02/09/10

    Of course the only reason RHH is going to cost a $1bil is Labour decided to build it on the Harbour in the 1st place. Otherwise it would have been 1/3rd of that. Maybe Tony understood that, knew week-knee Wilkie would us the hospital as an excuse and said ...Right… Read more »

 

Well silly old me. There I was thinking the 2010 federal election was about economic management, border protection, broadband and leadership.

Either, either, neither, neither…Kudelka in The Sunday Tele

Turns out it was about light rail for north Hobart, the reintroduction of tariffs for the banana industry, an hourly limit on poker machine betting, new rules governing the length of answers during Question Time and the urgent introduction of an emissions trading scheme.

For all the talk about who has the biggest mandate, a separate and more compelling point should be made about the emergence of a raft of left-field side issues as bargaining chips in the battle to form government. And that is – none of these independents has any mandate at all to use them as conditions for supporting the major party.

Latest 2 of 220 comments

 
  • Farkurnell says:

    07:53pm | 02/09/10

    Gee Thatmosis,with 13% of the electorate Raving Loony’s you better get out of Oz before its too late. I think you need a reality check , like it or not the Raving Loony’s are here to stay .Tony needs to wise up and accept the brave new world, and also… Read more »

  • Johnno says:

    07:50pm | 02/09/10

    “... is frightening”. Ever notice how conservative voters are always motivated by real or imagined fear? They always seem a scared bunch, seeking the reassurance and security of daddy’s hug. Excuse me, I must get my pitchfork, them boat people’s comin’ to steal my job. Read more »

 

People are discovering that food costs are soaring, electricity and government charges including water charges are on the increase and many families are needing to find savings in the family budget.

The Punch's daily meat intake

If recent reports by the United Nations are any indication then the savings can come from this unexpected phenomenon.

The worlwide non-profit initiative to promote Meatless Mondays and Fishless Fridays is encouraging the voluntary rationing of certain foods. This is not new as rationing was common practice during both World Wars. 

Latest 2 of 86 comments

 
  • Jayne says:

    07:11pm | 02/09/10

    Working in the complimentary health sector the biggest problem encountered is protein malnutrition. I have to tell people how important it is and try to get them eating more. Telling people to cut out fish and meat 2 days a week when they are not eating it that often is… Read more »

  • Talya says:

    07:05pm | 02/09/10

    @Sahara eek, Im a vegetarian and a Christian. looking for a roomie by any chance? I promise to keep the farts to a minimum, and my sickly complexion is more of a warm sunshine yellow, so that’s nice. My ‘rabid vegetarianism’ aside, the article does raise some good points. You… Read more »

 

Australia really needs to do something about its addiction to opinion polls.

Cartoon by The Australian's Bill Leak

The week following the election, just like the weeks that led up to it, was dominated by polls.

First came the local ones in the rural Independents’ electorates, which some interpreted as a new set of riding instructions to Messrs Katter, Windsor and Oakeshott.

Latest 2 of 12 comments

 
  • Ellen Bach says:

    07:40pm | 02/09/10

    Polls used as a rapid-fire quick indicator are incredibly useful tools for an educated society.  Trouble brews when they become damn lies etc.  to promote partisan agendas. Read more »

  • HT says:

    04:52pm | 02/09/10

    Spot on. Thank you! Read more »

 

Regardless of the outcome of this hung Parliament scenario; business and vested interest groups will be the winners in the medium to long term.

All three voices count. Picture:Kym Smith.

Forget the current wobbliness on the stock exchange and the suspension of investment and trade by some mining companies and multi-nationals; the opportunities posed for those wishing to engage with the independents and the incoming Government far outweigh the risks.

Latest 2 of 5 comments

 
  • Peter Oataway, Hay, NSW says:

    04:09pm | 02/09/10

    Bruce Hawker is Tony Windsor’s cousin not Rob Oakeshot’s ,,The King of the United Kingdom in World War One was the cousin of the Kaiser of Germany ...that didn’t stop them from going to war. Read more »

  • Tezza says:

    02:22pm | 02/09/10

    Of course, it will be a picnic for lobbyists and carpet baggers of all sorts. When Bruce Hawker starts giving advice to the independents, it’s not just because he turns out to be a cousin of Rob Oakeshot and wants to help. It’s because it’s his job as a lobbyist… Read more »

 

The great French cyclist, Laurent Fignon, who died this week from cancer, aged just 50, recalled being recognized by a man in the street.

The great Fignon

“Ah, I remember you: you’re the guy who lost the Tour by eight seconds.” “No, monsieur,” Fignon replied, “I’m the guy who won it twice.”

After losing the 3,285 kilometre race by a few seconds in the time-trial on the streets of Paris in 1989, it is little wonder that Fignon is most remembered for that year of the event. 

Latest 2 of 7 comments

 
  • Sam says:

    03:27pm | 02/09/10

    I recall him when I was in Italy in the eighties. His solo win in the Milano-San Remo was superb. I’m not sure about the helicopter claim though. Moser was a great time trialler, and had just broken the world hour record Read more »

  • tom says:

    02:27pm | 02/09/10

    one of France’s last great cycling champions. thank you Kevin Andrews. Read more »

 

As we patiently await the formation of the next federal government we should pause to reflect on what a hung Parliament may actually mean for consumers, small businesses and farmers.

Picture: David Sproule.

While clearly a very important issue, it’s one that hasn’t received the attention it deserves. For starters one would have to say that it wouldn’t take very much for consumers, small businesses and farmers to get a better deal. All too often both major parties have failed to deliver real and meaningful reforms. 

There have been obvious exceptions. We had the small business reforms in 1997 from Peter Reith and we had Peter Costello deliver the Birdsville Amendment against predatory pricing. We also have some exciting possible developments in South Australia where Labor State Backbencher, Tony Piccolo, has been pushing franchising law reforms. Western Australia is also fast becoming a battleground for possible small business reforms.

Latest 2 of 7 comments

 
  • Rose says:

    04:19pm | 02/09/10

    Abbott is not taking a stance on anything, he is behaving as if he feels that negotiating is beneath him, as if he is ‘entitled’ to be PM. Fact is, like or not, the Prime Minister, who-ever that may be, is going to be negotiating for the rest of this… Read more »

  • Anna says:

    03:29pm | 02/09/10

    I agree - after all the work they did to even the playing field for the election, I really don’t think the Lib/Nats Coalition want to lead an ineffective, compromised and crippled Government for 3 years. The better option would surely be to let the Labor/Greens Coalition tinker for 3… Read more »

 

The past few weeks have given us a mediocre campaign at best and left the electorate cynical. Can there be any other outcome when all both sides can come up with is an exchange of slogans, attention grabbing stunts and petty bickering.

Learned the ropes in student politics. Picture: Kym Smith.

Making sure they say what they believe to be safe and popular while avoiding the risks associated with delving deep into the important issues. Yes, student elections at ANU are all about shallow populism.

Wait… did you think I was talking about another election?

Latest 2 of 11 comments

 
  • wolf says:

    02:58pm | 02/09/10

    Didn’t penbo get his first paid journalism gig by running in a student election?  Perhaps he could offer some further insight in to the process… Read more »

  • gimme gimme says:

    12:43pm | 02/09/10

    So the girl who handed out a freebie won! Sounds like what K Rudd did in 2007 (i.e handing out money for votes) So I guess Money or in this case condoms talk!!! Read more »

 

Hollywood actress Salma Hayek was born in Mexico today in 1966.

Happy birthday. Picture: AP.

And it’s Thursday at The Punch, so what’s on your mind? Share it here.

Latest 2 of 23 comments

 
  • hot tub political machine says:

    05:23pm | 02/09/10

    Because your so polite fairsfair - no more politics from me on open threads Read more »

  • todays affair says:

    05:04pm | 02/09/10

    fairsfair, Watching sky news (cbs news) during the election campaign there was “breaking news” which actually was Juilia Gillard speaking to factory workers or Tony Abbott kissing babies! Now correct me if Im wrong I thought breaking news was for things like a natural disaster or a bus crash, seige… Read more »

 

Yet another member of the NSW Government has hit the wall over dodgy behaviour. Ports Minister Paul McLeay, son of the factional hack Leo, has been sacked for whiling away time in his ministerial office looking at pornographic websites.

McLeay talks to some police. And no this isn't a caption contest.

You can’t really blame the bloke. If you were sitting on a primary vote of 25 per cent and facing imminent electoral death, you’ve got to pass the hours somehow. His appetites didn’t stop at nudie sites, he also had a bit of a thing for online gambling. But the punter has now been punted with Premier Kristina Keneally telling the freakshow also known as the NSW Parliament just now that she had sought and received his resignation.

There’s a great text message doing the rounds in Labor circles this afternoon which reads as follows. “This behaviour is not the stand I expect of a minister,” Ms Keneally said. Why??!!

Latest 2 of 61 comments

 
  • Andrew says:

    05:14pm | 02/09/10

    Shame he didn’t use Fred Nile’s excuse: “Research”, it may have saved his bacon!! Read more »

  • Mr Pastry says:

    02:17pm | 02/09/10

    This subject has been covered sympathetically here by “Big Train” and certainly justifies his activities.  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zn6Z9djh8eA Read more »

 

Opinion from everywhere

  1. Hung parliament in wartime was one of our best [Robert Cavalier, The Australian]
  2. Green deal takes heat out of Abbott's fire [Lenore Taylor, National Times]
  3. Wikileaks, that sinking feeling [Mark Pesce, The Drum]
  4. Tony Blair's book does nothing for his reputation [Toby Young, Telegraph.co.uk]
  5. School removes word 'gay' from Kookaburra song [3AW Radio]
  6. Do you know your inheritance rights with a will? [Rebecca Gilsenan, The Daily Telegraph]
  7. Agriculture returns to the classroom [Ed Gannon, Herald Sun]
  8. The unfulfilled secret desires of men [Paul Sheehan, National Times]
  9. The books you must read [Jonathan Franzen, The Daily Beast]
  10. Are tests biased against kids that don't give a shit? [The Onion (satire)]

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Leo Shanahan

@Alex_Carlton there is no nice way for me to say i want to here that right now.

David Penberthy

RT @_leo_s: Abbott's Dr Evil moment: one billion dollars! And why he could be screwed now http://tinyurl.com/37mfmwh

Leo Shanahan

Abbott's Dr Evil moment: one billion dollars! And why he could be screwed now http://tinyurl.com/37mfmwh

David Penberthy

@Grant_Archer thanks mate

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Push poll

Vote early, vote often

Loading poll...

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Gillard and Abbott get a digital makeover

Gillard and Abbott get a digital makeover

Warning: this has nothing to do with politics. We thought we’d see how the Prime Minister and Opposition… Read more

25 comments

The story behind the picture

An inside view of the last days of the Gillard campaign

An inside view of the last days of the Gillard campaign

By all accounts this election has been really boring and as a photographer I wanted to do something different… Read more

23 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter