Aug 4th 2010 By Dan Solomon
Serving as an undercover agent sounds thrilling -- creating a fake identity, running around with criminals, infiltrating secret organizations. But everything we think we know about the trade of being an undercover agent comes from TV and movies.
In order to better understand what it's like to actually work undercover, we asked
Jay Dobyns, the ATF agent who successfully infiltrated the Hells Angels (and
wrote a book about the experience), and
Jack Garcia, who very nearly became a made man with
the Gambino crime family, to help separate myth from reality and tell us what it's
really like.
Creating a Cover Identity
There are various styles for creating a cover identity, but neither Dobyns nor Garcia suggests treating it like you're rolling up a D&D character.
"Some guys are pure method actors," Dobyns says. "But I was never able to do that. I've always been a what-you-see-is-what-you-get sort of guy. I'd talk to the suspects in the case the same way I'd talk to anybody."
Garcia concurs, for the most part: "I didn't do any outlandish background creation," he says, though entering the Mafia ranks, where most members grew up in the same neighborhood and have long family ties, required some specific details to be in place. "I was supposed to be a guy who just came in from Miami, so I found a cemetery that had a husband and wife with the same last name I was using, in case I was in Florida and the subjects in the case wanted to test me by going to visit their graves."