5346
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
NEW
|
---
|
Operation parameter in bindingOperation is of type QName
|
4567
|
nor
|
P1
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Typo in wsdl2.0 attachment URIs
|
6029
|
nor
|
P1
|
MacO
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Note on using xml:id should reference Canonical XML 1.1 and XML Signature, Second Edition
|
3599
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
ashok.malhotra
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Need a URI structure to refer to WSDL 1.0 definitions, etc.
|
3638
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
ashok.malhotra
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Need to be able to specify ordering between assertions
|
3639
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
ashok.malhotra
|
RESO
|
WONT
|
Which policy alternative was selected?
|
3730
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
ashok.malhotra
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
External WS-Policy Attachment to WSDL 2.0 components
|
3556
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
asirveda
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Suggested rewording of Introduction to WS-PolicyAttachment
|
3557
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
asirveda
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Add discussion/examples of domain expressions
|
3558
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
asirveda
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Remove example of use of domain expressions in section 4.2
|
3694
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
asirveda
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
WS-Policy Attachment for WSDL 2.0
|
3604
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
bparsia
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Goals section inadequate or unnecessary
|
3621
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
bparsia
|
RESO
|
WONT
|
Formal semantics
|
3622
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
bparsia
|
RESO
|
WONT
|
Policy assertion equivalence and generality
|
3623
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
bparsia
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Relation of Attachment to SAWSDL
|
3535
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
specify a W3C namespace URI
|
3543
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Definion of the term "processor" is poorly defined
|
3544
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
should ws-policy-attach permit use of BP1.1 amended extensibility points?
|
3827
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
References section contains reference to obsolete version of WS-RM policy.
|
3962
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
No media type has been assigned to ws-policy.
|
4039
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
WS-Policy does not define its relationship to XML Base
|
4045
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
scoping of wsdl1.1 identifiers spec
|
4103
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Primer] Questionable use of fictitious corp. name "Contoso Ltd."
|
4203
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
introduction unclear and misleading
|
4204
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
misleading text in sect 2.3
|
4205
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
editorial nits
|
4207
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
misleading text in section 2.2
|
4230
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
normative text masquerading as non-normative guidance
|
4306
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
update namespace document
|
4311
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
test suite framework?
|
4374
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Attachment] need to change qname for the ws-addr metadata elements in examples
|
4375
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] need to change qname for the ws-addr metadata elements in examples
|
4376
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Primer] need to change qname for the ws-addr metadata elements in examples
|
4544
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
policy vocabulary inconsistency post intersection as relates to AIN
|
4561
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
clarification of domain-specific processing
|
4582
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
test cases need coverage of nested policy for lax intersection
|
4859
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
chrisfer
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
clarify BP23
|
3602
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
Daniel.Roth
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
The absence of an assertion should not mean that the behavior is "explicitly prohibited"
|
3978
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
Daniel.Roth
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Clarify if Section 7 on defining new policy attachment mechanisms is necessary
|
3979
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
Daniel.Roth
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Clarify guidance in section 5.9.1 on referencing policy expressions
|
3982
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
Daniel.Roth
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] The introduction should state that the document only targets policy assertion authors
|
3990
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
Daniel.Roth
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Content in Section 5.7 is unclear
|
4074
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
Daniel.Roth
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Collection of unclear Guidance or text issues
|
4224
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
Daniel.Roth
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Section 4, last paragraph content is too restrictive - policy element information items are processed in multiple contexts
|
4225
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
Daniel.Roth
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Framework editorial issues
|
4226
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
Daniel.Roth
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Attachment editorial issues
|
3566
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
dmoberg
|
RESO
|
DUPL
|
Remove misleading phrasing of section 1.1 Goals section
|
3707
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
drsecure
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Add definition of "nested policy"
|
4127
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fabian.ritzmann
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Proposed WSDL 1.1 element identifiers can not deal with operation name overloading
|
4177
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fabian.ritzmann
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Disambiguate notational convention for choice syntax
|
4178
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fabian.ritzmann
|
RESO
|
WONT
|
Declaration of policy domains in policy expressions
|
4179
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fabian.ritzmann
|
RESO
|
WONT
|
Preferences for policy expressions
|
4198
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fabian.ritzmann
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Policy assertion semantics independent of attachment mechanism
|
4206
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fabian.ritzmann
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify treatment of policy assertion parameters in compatibility determination
|
3546
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
frederick.hirsch
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
WSDL 2.0 status recorded in Attachments 1.5 document
|
3549
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
frederick.hirsch
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Require assertions to be distinguished from parameter elements
|
3613
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
frederick.hirsch
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify conversion of compact to normal form in Framework section 4.3
|
3703
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
frederick.hirsch
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Element within policy expression must be an assertion
|
3708
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
frederick.hirsch
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Updated Security Considerations section in framework document: Add mention of use of XML Signature to sign policy
|
3710
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
frederick.hirsch
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify that policy assertion parameters are opaque to framework processing
|
3711
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
frederick.hirsch
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Add Cross-Product description to 4.3.3 in Framework
|
3952
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
frederick.hirsch
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Change optional example from MTOM to security (Guidelines and Primer)
|
3953
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
frederick.hirsch
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Remove language that use of security policy assertions forces nested assertions for other domains
|
3561
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Usage of Internationalized Resource Identifiers for W3C WS-Policy
|
3562
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify the relation of overlapping definitions in the framework
|
3705
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Definition of Interaction
|
3719
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Levels of indirection for policy references
|
3722
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
DUPL
|
Levels of indirection for policy references
|
3797
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
DUPL
|
Pl. remove references to proprietary documents
|
3815
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
A wg member neutral name is desirable
|
3894
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Definition of equivalence for WSDL 2.0 component model {policy} properties
|
3961
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial error in framework section 4.1example
|
3965
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify text surrounding PolicyReference and for usage of wsp:Name attribute
|
3980
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Should Assume Basic Understanding of WS-Policy
|
3981
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Section 4 Relevance to Assertion Design
|
3983
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Use 'Assertion Author (s)' Consistently
|
3984
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Assertion Parameters vs. Name Value Pairs
|
3985
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Section 5.3.1 should use the definition of policy assertion parameters from the Framework spec
|
3986
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Parameter vs. Nested Policy Decision at Domain Level?
|
3987
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Section 5.9 - Lifecycle of Assertions?
|
3988
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Section 8 Doesn't Illustrate How to Design an Assertion
|
3989
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Suggested Format
|
4035
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Guidelines Section 2 should account for impact of assertions that do not manifest on the wire, or only apply to one party but may still impact the ability to interoperate, depending on whether they may be ignored.
|
4038
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Nested policy in normal form - Example does not match expectations
|
4040
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Update guidelines to include discussion of ignorable
|
4041
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Update primer to mention ignorable as needed
|
4042
|
nor
|
P2
|
Linu
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial fix to Media type description
|
4068
|
nor
|
P2
|
Linu
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
XML Schema does not allow for validating xml:id in policy documents
|
4069
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Updating References for Use of xml:id
|
4072
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidance] Statements not relevant to assertion design
|
4073
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Free standing statements
|
4128
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Need references to WSDL 1.1 and WSDL 2.0 component syntax
|
4129
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Attaching Policies to EPRs
|
4130
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Ignorable assertions must be ignored
|
4188
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
LC Comments from SAWSDL WG
|
4208
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
identifiers should use WSDL 1.1 element names not WSDL 2.0 component names
|
4209
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Example 3.1 does not follow the algorithm in merging policies
|
4210
|
min
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
WSDL WG Editorial comments on Framework
|
4211
|
min
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
WSDL WG Editorial comments on Attachment
|
4212
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Use of empty policy for nesting should be exemplified
|
4235
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
clarification needed to sect 4.3 to indicate that the normalization algorithm can be applied to wsp:Policy element used as XML element policy attachment
|
4236
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
personal comment not a comment from the WS-RX TC
|
4238
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
framework spec does not formally define syntax (outline, etc) for compact form policy expression
|
4240
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Title: The distribution example does not follow the axioms in Section 4.3.3
|
4251
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[WSDL11Ids] Change syntax for some WSDL 1.1 identifiers
|
4253
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Primer] Basic Concepts section on Policy does not explain usage reasonably
|
4254
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Change of WSP namespace to be compliant with w3c namespace policy
|
4255
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Primer] Section 2.9 should also explain basic attaching
|
4263
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Primer] Add text to ignorable discussion on passing ignorable property of assertion to domain specific processing
|
4270
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Primer versioning example
|
4288
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Primer] Absence of Policy Assertions (editorial)
|
4292
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
WONT
|
Intersection mode is neither defaulted nor specified
|
4300
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Misuse of best practices in primer
|
4301
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Test case for xml:id
|
4304
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Test case for application/policy+xml media type
|
4307
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Update media type description
|
4318
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[All docs] Which WS-SecurityPolicy version should be used as a reference
|
4319
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] (Editorial) WS-RM(P) reference format should be consistent with other references
|
4339
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Update references to interoperability in Ignorable Policy Expressions section
|
4370
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Round 2 WSDL 1.1 input file contains invalid references
|
4379
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Note about c14n 1.1
|
4393
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Primer] Add text to strict and lax policy intersection discussion describing how a policy consumer can determine issues due to intersection mode conflicts
|
4394
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
WONT
|
Type of the WSDL 2.0 {policy} property?
|
4414
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Primer] Versioning and Extensibility cleanup in Primer
|
4456
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Minor issues with Round 2 WSDL 11 test files
|
4477
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial, example line number incorrect
|
4478
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial: line numbers in last example in section 4.1
|
4479
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial, note is obscure or unclear
|
4490
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Round4 negative tests
|
4522
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Namespace problems in the WSDL 1.1 and WSDL 2.0 External Attachment Test Cases.
|
4552
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Should the word "collection" be changed to something more specific?
|
4553
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Exact meaning of "all of the assertions in both alternatives"
|
4554
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Configurability and comformance of intersection algorithm
|
4555
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Should policy intersection be called policy intersection?
|
4556
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial Issue from David Hull
|
4559
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Versioning: Requests for Expired Services
|
4566
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Guideline G2 to be reconsidered
|
4568
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Incorrect namespaces in testcases
|
4571
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
round2 wsdl2 needs QNames not NCNames
|
4572
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Typo in wsp:URI in wsdl2.0 for round4
|
4575
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Minor Bugs in Round 2 WSDL 20 Test Cases from WSO2/Manjula
|
4577
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Need an example that doesn't intersect in Section 4.5, Framework
|
4579
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[New Issue] Context for Parent Policy Assertions and Nested Policy Expressions
|
4580
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
DUPL
|
[New Issue] Context for Parent Policy Assertions and Nested Policy Expressions
|
4583
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Duplicate assertions in an alternative
|
4584
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify how lax mode and ignorable assertions affect the intersection algorithm
|
4592
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
incorrect reference content
|
4598
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Some compact expressions appear not to have normal forms
|
4662
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Proposal for AI 305
|
4663
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Example for Section 8
|
4664
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Proposal for AI 286
|
4672
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
typo's in examples
|
4695
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial Comments on Guidelines
|
4762
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Media type section update
|
4831
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Updated References for WSDL v2.0 and WS-SecurityPolicy v1.2
|
4836
|
nor
|
P2
|
Linu
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
RFC4346 obsoletes RFC2246
|
4851
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Update C14N11 reference in WS-Policy Framework
|
4852
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Minor Editorial Comments
|
4853
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Two Free Standing Statements
|
4854
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Fictitious, why not real examples?
|
4857
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Primer] Updates For Nested Policy Expressions and Context for Primer
|
4858
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
update wsdl11 eii reference to WG Note
|
4861
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Section 5.6 needs to be refactored and rewritten
|
4862
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
What's an XML outline?
|
4889
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
LATE
|
Policies depend on message properties
|
4943
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Action 338 - Compatibility Matching at Nested Level
|
4945
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Update References - Framework and Attachment
|
4951
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
WONT
|
Need example of assertion showing ordering between assertions
|
5036
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial change proposals for the primer
|
5038
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
potential issues for primer and guidelines
|
5039
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
potential issues for primer and guidelines #2
|
5041
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial change proposals for the guidelines document
|
5043
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Follow up to 4654
|
5044
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Proposal for AI 339
|
5045
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
WONT
|
Why did intersection fail?
|
5128
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
editorial nit in example in section 5.3.2
|
5184
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial Changes - Guidelines
|
5185
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Guidelines - BP 1 and 21 are Duplicates
|
5186
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Update References - Guidelines
|
5187
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Update References - Primer
|
5188
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Incorrect Examples in Section 4 - Primer
|
5189
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Guidelines - BP 19 Lacks Motivation
|
5204
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Remove term vocabulary from primer
|
5206
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Ordering of Assertions
|
5218
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
editorial changes sect 5.7,1
|
5219
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Primer 3.6 Policy Retrieval
|
5220
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Expression author versus provider of policy expressions
|
5226
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Policy Retrieval Algorithms
|
5299
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Use final WS-SecurityPolicy 1.2 for interop tests
|
6030
|
nor
|
P2
|
MacO
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Note on using xml:id should reference Canonical XML 1.1 and XML Signature, Second Edition
|
6619
|
min
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Attachment 3.4.1 - XML outline uses wsp:PolicyReference where it should be wsp:PolicyAttachment
|
3577
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
gdaniels
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Semantics of successful intersection determined by domain-specific assertion content
|
3620
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
gdaniels
|
RESO
|
LATE
|
Policy Attachment to WS-Addr EndpointReferences
|
3565
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Framework and domain specific policy assertions
|
3619
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
add an inssue on coordination with other working groups
|
3706
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
editors to clarify the use of the term "domain"
|
3791
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
primer/guidelines overlap
|
3792
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
section 4 of the primer overlaps with the guidelines document
|
3794
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Section 3 overlap of primer with guidelines
|
3795
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Section 2.4- usefulness
|
4213
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Primer] Use of empty policy for nesting should be exemplified
|
4654
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Guidelines for Policy Attachment
|
4660
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Best Practice Statments should be statements
|
4661
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
mhondo
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Reorganize guidance on XML Info Set representation
|
3966
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
monica.martin
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Inconsistency in Primer re: PolicyReference Extensibility
|
4150
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
monica.martin
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Duplicate text exists in Section 3 and 3.2, PolicyAttachments
|
4196
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
monica.martin
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify namespace restrictions (Framework and Primer)
|
4197
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
monica.martin
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Inconsistency on treatment of unknown extensibility elements (Framework, Primer, Guidelines)
|
3590
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
orchard
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Policy framework should document extensibility points using {any} and @{any} in xpath-like expressions, and define these in Notational Conventions section
|
3662
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
orchard
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Use of element wildcard ##any namespace vs ##other namespace
|
4558
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
orchard
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Scalability and performance problems with expressing allowable nested policy assertions
|
4331
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
pcotton
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
WSDL WG comment 1
|
4332
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
pcotton
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
WSDL WG comment 2
|
3656
|
nor
|
P2
|
Linu
|
plh
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Using UsingAddressing Extension Element as a WS-Policy assertion
|
3552
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
prasad.yendluri
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Policy Application to Web services Model description inaccurate
|
3553
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
prasad.yendluri
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Policy Compatibility Check must account for level of Nesting of Policy Alternatives
|
3554
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
prasad.yendluri
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
"Policy Alternatives" and "Policy" need proper definition
|
4195
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
prasad.yendluri
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
How to ignore some of the assertions marked �Ignorable� only?
|
4262
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
prasad.yendluri
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Use of @wsp:optional and @wsp:Ignorable on the same assertion
|
4389
|
maj
|
P2
|
All
|
prasad.yendluri
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
WS-Policy 1.5 Attachment UDDI tModel keys and related references outdated
|
4391
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
prasad.yendluri
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Update WS-Policy 1.5 Attachment to point to latest UDDI specs in the references section
|
3545
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
public-ws-policy-eds
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
use of {any} and {@any} in xpath-like expressions not defined in Notational Conventions section
|
3752
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
ritzmann
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify restrictions of ID type usage
|
3753
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
ritzmann
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Example 1-1 is not a complete security policy
|
3723
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
sergey.beryozkin
|
RESO
|
INVA
|
Non-normative recommendation on how effective polices should be calculated when a policy is associated with an arbitrary XML element.
|
3789
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
sergey.beryozkin
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify usage of assertions with no behavioral requirements on the requester
|
3709
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
tboubez
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Editorial corrections and clarifications from UDDI TC
|
3559
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
umit.yalcinalp
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Conformance Sections needed for both specs
|
3560
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
umit.yalcinalp
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
The framework specification should also enable the usage of xml:id
|
3564
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
umit.yalcinalp
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Optional Assertions may not be usable in all circumstances
|
3617
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
umit.yalcinalp
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Namespace URI versioning Policy is not clear
|
3809
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
umit.yalcinalp
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Primer uses an Assertion that does not exist
|
4138
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
umit.yalcinalp
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Normalization Algorithm is broken (single conjunctive expressions)
|
4141
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
umit.yalcinalp
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Policy parameter definition is not accurate
|
4142
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
umit.yalcinalp
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Contradictory recommendation for nesting and intersection
|
3712
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
vladislav.bezrukov
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
wsp:PolicyReference can be used in any place where you can use wsp:Policy
|
3547
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
william.henry
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify the difference between Web Services Policy and Web Services Policy 1.5 - Framework in the Introduction
|
3605
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
william.henry
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Typo wsp:tPolicyURIs in Section 3.3 first example
|
3721
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
william.henry
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
New Attribute keyword to identify 'local' policies
|
3563
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
yakov.sverdlov
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Modify wording about a Web Service in the Introduction
|
3586
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
yakov.sverdlov
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Remove misleading reference to a Requester policy.
|
3607
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
yakov.sverdlov
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Better describe policy language capabilities in the Introduction
|
3672
|
nor
|
P2
|
othe
|
yakov.sverdlov
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Clarify the policy model for Web Services
|
3793
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
yakov.sverdlov
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
Add example about policies in the context of relationships between multiple entities
|
4573
|
nor
|
P3
|
Wind
|
prasad.yendluri
|
RESO
|
FIXE
|
[Guidelines] Use one of Guidelines, Best Practices or Good Practices Consistently
|
3616
|
enh
|
P4
|
All
|
tboubez
|
RESO
|
WONT
|
Policy Negotiation
|
3548
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
frederick.hirsch
|
CLOS
|
INVA
|
Normalization should make empty nested policy elements
|
3720
|
nor
|
P2
|
Wind
|
fsasaki
|
CLOS
|
FIXE
|
Terms should be defined/targeted in the appropriate sections of the spec
|
3551
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
prasad.yendluri
|
CLOS
|
FIXE
|
Misc. (editorial) corrections throughout
|
3592
|
nor
|
P2
|
All
|
seumas.soltysik
|
CLOS
|
FIXE
|
Implementation APIs for WS-Policy should not simply wrap DOM elements
|