Does Mighty Putty Work?

Update: I removed the embedded video since it was autoplaying. Sorry about that!

Harry Sawyers at This Old House's "Hardware Aisle" wants to know about the As-Seen-On-TV product "Mighty Putty," as sold by the screaming monotone of well-groomed Billy Mays, actually works.

Well, does it?

Mighty Putty: Does it work? [Hardware Aisle]


Discussion

Take a look at this
#1 posted by Anonymous , March 3, 2008 10:22 AM

It's just epoxy putty, which you can get at any hardware store. It's good stuff, almost as good as he says it is, but how much of it do you need?

Take a look at this

We use something 'mighty similar' here where I work called 'Dura Bond Epoxy Putty' from a co. called 'Pro Chem'...
from the label:
'Dura Bond will PLUG and SEAL practically anything that leaks, it will PATCH holes and cracks, MEND almost anything that is broken. It is excellent for REBUILDING or FABRICATING PARTS and as an all-purpose adhesive for metals, wood, glass, masonry, ceramics, and many plastics. It can be drilled, tapped, filled, sanded, and painted like metal. Sets steel-hard in 20 minutes.'
It's even set up the same - an inner 'tube' of one material, surrounded by an outer 'tube' - rip off a chunk, mush it all together (but work fast!), and apply it to whatever ya got ...

So, yeah, if this 'Mighty Putty' is similar, it should work - this Dura Putty hardens like ceramic very quickly (and gets quite warm while doing so - epoxy-like chemical reactions going on, dontcha know) ....

Take a look at this

When I first saw it, I thought of the epoxy putty that's available at basically any auto parts store - it works the same way (and smells truly foul), and works well if you can use enough (but I've certainly had cases where either the mating surfaces were too small or the stresses were such that it couldn't hold)

On a side note - it's kind of obnoxious to have the video start auto playing - I just spent five minutes looking for the source of Billy Mays's annoying voice.

Take a look at this

Yep, available at the hardware store, though if you need 6 tubes of the stuff his price is not a complete rip off - unless shipping is more than a couple of bucks.

Agree with #3 - having the video auto-play is truly annoying.

Take a look at this

I don't know if it works, but from seeing that commercial I'm now disturbed by the possibility that we (as a society) are not using epoxy putty to its full potential.

Billy Mays doesn't just glue a coffee cup handle back on--he makes a whole NEW handle out of putty. Maybe we could make the whole CUP out of putty. Maybe we could make the whole KITCHEN out of putty. Maybe we could make SEATTLE out of putty.

Am I crazy? Or are alien explorers going to be digging through our ruins a few hundred years hence, saying "The fools! They had mastered epoxy putty technology. Yet they stubbornly clung to their pre-putty ways, and in the end, destroyed themselves!"

Take a look at this
#6 posted by Kid Author Profile Page, March 3, 2008 11:35 AM

I was wondering about that the whole time I saw the ad, too. It is actually the only one thing that I am interested in. One of my friends' friend used to buy every single thing she saw on TV, so they can try if it works. Usually they break or are left in a corner in a week or two.

Take a look at this

Ahh damn. he was inches away from getting run over by that fully loaded tractor-trailer. Someday, an accident will silence that voice forever.

Take a look at this
#8 posted by Fnarf , March 3, 2008 12:50 PM

Does anyone else ever wonder what it must be like to live with Billy May? "HEY, DO YOU THINK I COULD GET A LITTLE MORE COFFEE, SWEETHEART?! THANK YOU!!!! HEY, DID YOU SEE THIS ARTICLE IN THE PAPER?! LOOKS LIKE THEY'RE PUTTING IN A NEW SUPERMARKET DOWN BY (blam, sound of shotgun followed by blessed silence).

Take a look at this

FNARF - beat me to it.

God I hate Billy May. I thought that ponytailed freak Tony Little was annoying.

Most nights its the megatone/monatone voice of Billy May that alerts me that I have fallen asleep on the sofa in front of the TV again.

Take a look at this

I've had varying degrees of success with the auto parts store version (of which I am convinced Mighty Putty is just a rebranding). It has worked for some home applications, but I used it to fix a broken car door lock. Someone tried to break into my truck by busting out the lock. I removed the door panel, and was able to put the lock back in place, but the original bracket suffered some damage. I used some of the putty to repair it, and it worked well until the temp dropped below freezing. I suspect that either the putty shrinks, or some other component, and that it let loose.

Oh well.

Take a look at this

Let me start by saying that, not only do I love Billy Mays with every thread of every fiber of my being, but every time his Mighty Putty infomercial flickers onto late-nite TV, I have to stop myself from running to the phone to immediately order. I asked everyone I knew to give me Mighty Putty for Xmas, and no one did. I have a weird, wooden Amish chair that needs some serious fixing.

Take a look at this
#12 posted by timmaah , March 4, 2008 5:57 AM

Our local new people ordered some and tried it..

The only thing they couldn't get it to do was pull a big truck...

http://www.wptz.com/video/15238520/index.html

Take a look at this

I bet it could have pulled the truck if they used the same device as in the commercial. If you watch closely, you'll see that his device has lots of holes, that the putty could squeeze into. This device transformed the tension stress into a shearing stress (which, given the surface area, is much more easily handled).

I've seen metal chain snap like a twig trying to help pull a big rig out of the mud (it wasn't sunk in, just didn't have traction). So I'm not surprised that it failed the news people's test.

Take a look at this
#14 posted by Anonymous , March 4, 2008 10:23 AM

no, it most certainly doesn't. it wouldn't even hold up a lightweight, full length mirror purchased from Bed Bath & Beyond on the backside of my bedroom door.

Post a comment

Anonymous